new york times movie review the power of the dog

Movie Reviews

Tv/streaming, collections, chaz's journal, great movies, contributors, the power of the dog.

Now streaming on:

Benedict Cumberbatch is perhaps not the first actor that springs to mind when thinking of casting a Western, but under the direction of Jane Campion in her stellar drama “The Power of the Dog,” he’s just what the movie needs. Covered head-to-toe in dirt for most of the film, he embodies a character in a masculine crisis. He has a constant need to prove he's the roughest, toughest leader in a wolf pack of cowboys, possibly to hide his adoration and affection for the long-gone man who taught him more than just how to ride a horse. Phil (Cumberbatch) dominates the pecking order of any room he’s in through cruel remarks and an irreverence towards authority. His eyes are cold as mountain air; his face is a stone façade against the world; his tongue is as sharp as a snake fang. Gone are the quirky and endearing characters that Cumberbatch has played in the past. Here, coiled like a predator in wait, Cumberbatch is perhaps more fearsome than as his deep-voiced villains in “The Hobbit” and “ Star Trek Into Darkness .” He moves through the movie like an unsheathed knife, cutting anyone unlucky enough to get close. 

Cumberbatch’s Phil is the rough and tumble Remus to the movie’s kinder Romulus, his brother George ( Jesse Plemons ). Where Phil is calloused and mean, George is gentler and more soft-spoken, often at the mercy of his brother’s teasing. At a stop at a restaurant, Phil harshly taunts Rose ( Kirsten Dunst ), a widow running the joint, and her son Peter ( Kodi Smit-McPhee ), who Phil bullies until Peter walks off the job and leaves his mother in tears. George reaches out to comfort her, and ends up falling for her. This enrages Phil, who takes the loss of his brother to a woman quite badly. He steps up his intimidation of Rose and Peter, like intensifying heat with a magnifying glass. That is, until Peter tries to spend more time with Phil. The unlikely camaraderie unlocks a number of secrets and hidden intentions, changing everyone’s relationship to each other. 

Using New Zealand for 1920s Montana, writer/director Campion sets this quiet-yet-angry Western against a harsh background that’s both beautiful and imposing. For Peter, it presents a hardened masculinity he must learn to overcome. For Phil, this windswept nature is an escape from the life of privilege he wants no part of. It is on the back of a horse that he found himself, and it is on those cow paths, mountain passes, and hidden rivers that he learned to disguise his desires. 

Campion's adaptation of Thomas Savage ’s novel of the same name strips out many details from the book and takes it back to its rawest in-the-moment elements. Backstory is filled in quickly and briefly in dialogue, if it’s ever filled in at all. There are no flashbacks, just a few scenes of characters sharing their past with each other. Campion and her cinematographer Ari Wegner write whole character studies in their close-ups. From this perspective, we get a sense of what the cast may never verbalize. It’s in the pained and panicked look on Rose’s face when she begins drinking after another round of Phil’s harassment. It’s in the steely glares Peter shoots Phil when he’s being picked on. It’s in George’s downward gazes at the floor, knowing he is helpless to stop his brother’s torments. It’s in the rage on Phil’s face as he realizes his tight-knit relationship with his brother is coming to an end with George’s marriage to Rose. It’s an approach Campion has used in her earlier works like “ An Angel at My Table ” and “ The Piano ,” the latter of which follows a main character, Ada ( Holly Hunter ), who cannot speak, but uses her face and sharply gestured sign language to get her point across. There is no doubt when Ada has something to share in “The Piano,” and through Phil’s movement, body language and reactions, Cumberbatch also speaks volumes with every scowl and every defiant smile. 

Many of Campion’s movies also focus on shifting power dynamics between characters: who has power, who loses it, and how they gain it back. Sometimes, this is in the form of women fighting to be heard, like in “ Sweetie ” or “ Bright Star .” But in “The Power of the Dog,” Rose’s entrance into the family is perceived as a threat, a challenge to established order. Phil extends her no kindness, slyly creating a toxic environment that poisons her, in order to retain power over his brother, their business and who is in charge around their stately mansion. She’s like an existential threat to him: she represents the sex he doesn’t desire and someone he doesn’t yet have under control. The truce between Phil and Peter unnerves Rose more, afraid of the influence he may have on her son. She loses herself in the bottle, just as Peter stands up to Phil’s bullying. It's a riveting dance between them all, waiting to see how it all will end once the music stops.

Speaking of the music, “The Power of the Dog” contains some of the best use of music in a movie this year. Jonny Greenwood ’s work underlines and emphasizes many of the actions playing out on-screen. String compositions twist and turn as sharply as the movie’s plot, like a jagged undercurrent pulling our emotions in certain directions. The sounds of sweet violins sour, while softer notes swell into intense waves. The changes are quick, a nod to the tense dynamics between the brothers, the widow, and her son. Many of the songs use plucked strings to create an air of uneasy anticipation, as if cantering into danger. Rows of violins join in to heighten this uneasy feeling, almost awakening our fight or flight response. The music doesn't stray too far from the prototypical Western sound yet adds these extra layers of foreboding throughout.

“The Power of the Dog” revels in this suspenseful place much like Phil prefers working with cattle than dealing with high society. Though the movie starts at a gentle pace, it doesn’t stay there long. There is so much layered desire, hatred, and domination that soon comes rolling out to disturb everyone’s uneasy peace. The game of wits between Phil and everyone else is a chilling one to watch, and it’s exactly the kind of end-of-the-year movie to finish things with a bang.

In theaters today and on Netflix on December 1st.

Monica Castillo

Monica Castillo is a critic, journalist, programmer, and curator based in New York City. She is the Senior Film Programmer at the Jacob Burns Film Center and a contributor to  RogerEbert.com .

Now playing

Borderlands

Brian tallerico.

It Ends with Us

Marya e. gates.

The Becomers

Matt zoller seitz.

Film Credits

The Power of the Dog (2021)

Rated R for brief sexual content/full nudity.

126 minutes

Benedict Cumberbatch as Phil Burbank

Kirsten Dunst as Rose Gordon-Burbank

Jesse Plemons as George Burbank

Kodi Smit-McPhee as Peter Gordon

Frances Conroy as Old Lady

Keith Carradine as Governor Edward

Thomasin McKenzie as Lola

Genevieve Lemon as Mrs. Lewis

Adam Beach as Edward Nappo

• Jane Campion

Writer (based on the novel by)

• Thomas Savage

Cinematographer

• Peter Sciberras
• Jonny Greenwood

Latest blog posts

13 Films Illuminate Locarno Film Festival's Columbia Pictures Retrospective

Apple TV+'s Pachinko Expands Its Narrative Palate For An Emotional Season Two

Tina Mabry and Edward Kelsey Moore on the Joy and Uplift of The Supremes at Earl's All-You-Can-Eat

The Adams Family Gets Goopy in Hell Hole

• Skip to main content
• Keyboard shortcuts for audio player

Movie Reviews

• LISTEN & FOLLOW
• Apple Podcasts
• Amazon Music

Your support helps make our show possible and unlocks access to our sponsor-free feed.

Rugged masculinity takes a dark turn in 'The Power of the Dog'

Justin Chang

Benedict Cumberbatch is the picture of rugged American masculinity in The Power of the Dog. Kirsty Griffin/Netflix hide caption

Benedict Cumberbatch is the picture of rugged American masculinity in The Power of the Dog.

The great New Zealand writer-director Jane Campion has long been acclaimed for her films about the complex inner lives of women, notably in 19th-century dramas like The Portrait of a Lady , Bright Star and especially The Piano. Her tense and gripping new movie, The Power of the Dog , thus marks something of a departure. It stars a superb Benedict Cumberbatch as a 1920s Montana rancher named Phil Burbank who's the very picture of rugged American masculinity.

Phil seems at one with the land and all its living creatures, whether he's riding a horse, leading a cattle drive or bathing in a muddy river. He's also a sadist, a fascinatingly conflicted monster, and one of the scariest characters you're likely to meet this year.

The movie, which Campion adapted from a 1967 novel by Thomas Savage, looks a lot like a Western, full of somber gray skies and craggy vistas that are magnificently shot by the cinematographer Ari Wegner. But it's more like a tightly wound psychological thriller that just happens to play out on an epic canvas, and it's full of secrets and surprises that it's slow to reveal.

The Two-Way

'sherlock' star benedict cumberbatch saves cyclist from muggers.

We first meet Phil and his brother, George, played by Jesse Plemons, who's his opposite in every respect: gentlemanly, polite, neatly dressed. The two run a ranch together and get along fine for the most part, with George genially absorbing every casual insult, like "fatso," that Phil throws his way.

But everything changes one evening when they're traveling with their men and stop for dinner at an inn. They're served by the owner, Rose Gordon, played by Kirsten Dunst, and her son, Peter, played by the Australian actor Kodi Smit-McPhee. As they're being waited on, Phil sneers at the intricately cut paper flowers decorating the table, which Peter made, and then mocks the boy's neat and precise manners.

Rose is devastated by Phil's humiliating attack on her son, and George, who knows all too well how cruel his brother can be, is there to comfort her. They soon fall in love and marry. It's worth noting that Dunst and Plemons are a couple in real life, which makes the tenderness of their on-screen marriage all the more touching.

George proves a considerate and generous husband, even paying for Peter to attend medical school. But he's unable to protect his new wife from the wrath of his brother. When Rose moves onto the ranch, Phil dismisses her as a gold digger and launches a vicious campaign of psychological abuse, driving Rose into depression and alcoholism.

The Power of the Dog really hits its stride in these moments; nothing overtly terrible happens, but the emotional violence that Phil inflicts on everyone in his midst is brutal to watch. Campion draws out the tension with exquisite subtlety, aided by an unnerving score by Jonny Greenwood and by four actors who could not be more ideally cast.

Few performers can break your heart like Dunst, whose face becomes a landscape of pain as all Rose's initial happiness drains away . Plemons is sympathetic as the decent but ultimately helpless George. In some ways the most intriguing character here is Peter, who eventually returns home from school to visit his mother and once more becomes a target of Phil's scorn. But Smit-McPhee's watchful, intelligent presence suggests that Peter is a more formidable adversary than he appears.

Before long, Peter and Phil strike up an odd sort of friendship, with Phil teaching Peter how to ride a horse and other cowboy rites of passage. But both men's motives remain ambiguous.

Cumberbatch has always been a marvelous actor, but he simply outdoes himself here. It's remarkable how easily this elegant British heartthrob, known for playing brainy types like Sherlock Holmes, Alan Turing and, yes, Doctor Strange, slips into the boots and spurs of a man of the Old West. But without giving away too much, there are deeper, more subversive layers to Cumberbatch's performance that feel consistent with Campion's past explorations of gender.

It's been 11 years since Campion made a new movie, though in the meantime she's co-written and co-directed two seasons of the crime drama series Top of the Lake . It's wonderful to have her back making gorgeously unsettling psychodramas in which the wildness of her landscapes matches the inner turbulence of her characters. And speaking of landscapes: The movie was actually shot in New Zealand, which does a pretty good job of passing as Montana. It's just one more way The Power of the Dog reminds us that appearances can be deceiving, and the most startling truths are often hiding in plain sight.

‘The Power of the Dog’ Review: Jane Campion’s Psychodramatic Western Is Impeccably Crafted but Lacks the Major Voices of ‘The Piano’

Benedict Cumberbatch and Jesse Plemons play brothers dueling over the theme of tolerance.

By Owen Gleiberman

Owen Gleiberman

Chief Film Critic

• ‘Blink Twice’ Review: Zoë Kravitz Proves She’s a Total Filmmaker in a #MeToo-Meets-‘Midsommar’ Thriller Starring a Sinister Channing Tatum 6 days ago
• Will the People Who Say They Love Cinema the Most Come Back to the Movies? 1 week ago
• ‘The Deliverance’ Review: Lee Daniels Directs a Demonic-Possession Movie in Which the Real Demons Are Personal (and Flamboyant) 1 week ago

Jane Campion is a great filmmaker who has always marched to a different (at times dissonant) drummer. But I suspect I’m far from alone when I say that I’ve long yearned to see her make another movie that can speak with the populist poetry and passion of “The Piano” — her most famous and successful film, and also (tellingly) her most artful. I raise the issue because “ The Power of the Dog ,”  Campion’s eighth feature in 30 years, is a frontier Western made with a stately and austere poker-faced modernist classicism, and roiling undercurrents, that sometimes bring the earlier film to mind. It’s a movie in which Campion, who shot it in her native New Zealand, works with a full-scale, at times painterly precision and control. It’s also a socially conscious psychodrama that builds, over time, to a full boil.

Related Stories

2024 Live Music Business Is Driving Record Revenues, but Some Data Points Raise Concerns

Oasis' Liam and Noel Gallagher Drop Biggest Hint Yet That Group Is Reuniting

Yet there’s a key difference between this movie and “The Piano.” In the earlier film, Holly Hunter played a woman who chose not to speak but declaimed her spirit with the most enthralling inner voice of any movie character that year. In “The Power of the Dog,” the characters have secrets, buried motives, hidden drives, yet the filmmaker treats them all, in a certain way, like puzzle pieces, fitting them into a grand scheme that connects with the audience in an overly programmatic way. The film’s message is unassailable, but that isn’t the same thing as devastating, which is what “The Power of the Dog” wants to be.

Popular on Variety

Reaching back to a Hollywood tradition built on films like “East of Eden,” and also to Terrence Malick’s rural art-house parable “Days of Heaven,” Campion, who wrote the script (based on Thomas Savage’s 1967 novel), centers the tale on two adult brothers who have spent enough of their lives intertwined to know just how different they are. The movie is set in 1925 in the mountain wilds of Montana, where the Burbank brothers, Phil ( Benedict Cumberbatch ) and George ( Jesse Plemons ), preside over a sprawling property on which they raise livestock and train horses. They’re successful ranchers, with money in the bank and a farmhouse mansion done up in mahogany paneling, with art on the walls right next to the trophy heads.

But these two are fatal opposites. Phil, played by Cumberbatch as a drawling cowboy monomaniac with a mean leer that makes him seem at times like an evil Dennis Quaid, is a haughty macho customer who rolls his own cigarettes, taunts his brother by calling him “Fatso,” and likes nothing better than to ride the range and go boozing and whoring with his stable of hired hands. He’s also got an over-the-top fixation on Bronco Henry, the cowboy from their youth who taught them everything they know. By contrast, George, played by Plemons in bow ties and bowler hats, is a mild officious type who’s the civilized superego to his brother’s rawhide id.

The tension between these two is already simmering when fate, in the middle of a cattle drive, takes them to a rooming house run by Rose (Kirsten Dunst). She’s a widow with a teenage son, Peter (Kodi Smit-McPhee), an aspiring medical student who speaks with a lisp, carries his folded wine napkin just so, and has a yen for crafting intricate fake flowers out of paper. As the cowhands sit down to their fried-chicken dinner, Phil zeroes in on the slender boy like a predator. “Ain’t them purdy,” he says of the flowers, then mocks the boy’s lisp with savage sarcasm. The contempt on display needs no explanation, but George, while he stays silent, is of a different mind. He’s not a homophobic macho in chaps. He’s a courtly nerd who knows he’s approaching middle age, and he makes a decision that shocks Phil and gets sprung on the audience so that we’re caught off guard too. He pays a visit to Rose, and the next thing you know the two are married. He’s bringing Rose and Peter to live on the ranch. Which, from Phil’s point-of-view, kind of throws a monkey wrench into their manly cowboy paradise.

“The Power of the Dog” starts off as a testy romantic fable of sibling rivalry, with Phil, in his crafty way, hellbent on destroying the domestic tranquility that his brother has found, and that he doesn’t believe in. It’s not clear that George believes in it either. He buys Rose a baby grand piano and tries to give her the life she wants, but he’s not around enough to make that stick, and she turns to nipping from bottles of bourbon she hides around the house. Kirsten Dunst does depressive fragility with consummate grace, but I wish the movie gave her something to play besides tremulous ragged despair. I also wish that Jesse Plemons, after a good first act or two, didn’t fade out of the center of the story.

The movie becomes a kind of showdown between Phil and the people he sees as interlopers. Rose ups the ante when she gives Phil’s cowhides away to their Native American neighbors; it seems that Phil doesn’t like indigenous traders any more than he likes lisping flower makers. There are good sinister scenes like one in which Phil sits playing the banjo, mocking the piano piece that Rose is rehearsing in nervous anticipation of a dinner party with the governor (played by a wily Keith Carradine). The crucial twist is that Phil, under his nastiness, is playing out his own buried longing. That reverence for Bronco Henry? It starts to look like an eroticized obsession — or maybe the twisted response to abuse. When Phil, to our surprise, starts to take Peter “under his wing” (and starts to weave a phallic rodeo braid), we’re primed to look for dark echoes of that relationship.

All of this should build, slowly and inexorably, in force and emotion. But for a film that’s actually, at heart, rather tidy and old-fashioned in its triangular gamesmanship, “The Power of the Dog” needed to get to a more bruising catharsis. In its crucial last act, the film becomes too oblique. Cumberbatch has the showpiece role, and he’s good, but there’s not enough dramatic layering to Phil’s repression and violence. Campion has made a movie whose dramatic upshot is to denounce homophobia — an unassailable message. But maybe, at this point, not a revelatory one. “The Piano” was wrenching because it channeled the passion that social oppression couldn’t hold back. “The Power of the Dog” is more like an artful diagram of passion.

Reviewed at Digital Arts, Aug. 19, 2021. MPAA Rating: R. Running time: 125 MIN.

• Production: A Netflix release, in association with New Zealand Film Commission, Cross City Films, BBC Film, and Brightstare, of a See-Saw Films, Bad Girl Creek, Max Films production. Producers: Jane Campion, Tanya Seghatchian, Emile Sherman, Iain Canning, Roger Frappier. Executive producers: Simon Gillis, Rose Garnett, John Woodward.
• Crew: Director, screenplay: Jane Campion. Camera: Ari Wegner. Editor: Peter Sciberras. Music: Jonny Greenwood.
• With: Benedict Cumberbatch, Kirsten Dunst, Jesse Plemons, Kodi Smit-McPhee, Thomasin McKenzie, Genevieve Lemon, Peter Carroll, Alison Bruce, Keith Carradine, Frances Conroy.

More from Variety

Ilana Glazer Sets Hulu Stand-Up Special ‘Human Magic’

How Media Companies Medal in a Different Olympics: European Video Market Share

Hollywood Must Define AI Technical Standards to Prep for Its Future    

More from our brands, why are donald trump and tim walz both talking about bruce springsteen.

7 Can’t-Miss Sparkling Wines to Celebrate the Holidays

Commanders Commit to a New, Improved Sean Taylor Statue

The Best Loofahs and Body Scrubbers, According to Dermatologists

Orphan Black: Echoes Finale: Creator Anna Fishko Talks Tatiana Maslany, [Spoiler]’s Fate and Hopes for Season 2

Find anything you save across the site in your account

“The Power of the Dog” is Jane Campion’s Anti-Western

The new film from Jane Campion, “The Power of the Dog,” is based on Thomas Savage’s novel of the same name, published in 1967. The title echoes the Twenty-second Psalm, in the King James Bible: “Deliver my soul from the sword; my darling from the power of the dog.” As the movie ends, you can’t help asking yourself: Who exactly is the dog, and who’s the darling?

The year is 1925, and the place is Montana, which is played onscreen by Campion’s native New Zealand. Whether it fulfills the role convincingly—not least in regard to trees and vegetation—is a question that only Montanans will be qualified to answer. What’s undeniable is the glory of the hills, camel-colored and weirdly folded, that loom in the backdrop of the tale. We are in ranching country, though where we are, at any given moment, isn’t always clear; it takes a while to get one’s bearings, economic as much as geographical. As Annie Proulx has noted, in an afterword to Savage’s book, few of us can understand “the combination of hard physical work and quiet wealth that characterized some of the old ranches.”

This is especially true of the Burbank clan. Their bastion is a mansion, richly furnished, with dark wood panelling, like a gentlemen’s club. But look at the gentlemen. George Burbank (Jesse Plemons) is stout, compliant, and ill at ease; even on horseback, he wears a black suit. By contrast, his brother, Phil ( Benedict Cumberbatch ), cuts a lean and leathery figure and spurns the trappings of his affluence, preferring the great outdoors. We learn that he graduated Phi Beta Kappa from Yale, yet refinement of any sort disgusts him; when the governor of the state comes to dine, George requests that Phil clean himself up beforehand. No luck. As Phil says, “I stink and I like it.”

This rub of the rough against the smooth—of wilder ways confronting more cultivated ones—will be familiar to followers of Campion. Who can forget “The Piano” (1993), and the sight of Holly Hunter, in her bonnet and her billowing skirt, being borne ashore, amid a surge of waves, and deposited on the alien sands of New Zealand? As for ill-matched siblings, they were crucial to Campion’s début film, “Sweetie” (1989), whose title character trampled on the life of her sister. Yet something about the clashes in “The Power of the Dog” feels overworked and set up. On a prosaic level, I never quite believed in George and Phil as brothers, and the movie’s closeups tend to belabor a symbolic point: artificial flowers, crafted from cut paper; a hand caressing the curves of a well-buffed saddle; a bull calf being castrated. On the page, mind you, Savage describes the discarded testicles being tossed onto the fire, where they explode like popcorn, so moviegoers get off lightly.

The pivot of the plot is Rose Gordon (Kirsten Dunst), a widow who runs a boarding house. She has a son, an otherworldly creature named Peter (Kodi Smit-McPhee); as thin as a sapling, and flitting to and fro in white shoes, he is the one who makes the flowers. When the ranchers stop at Rose’s place for a meal, Phil taunts Peter, to the amusement of the tough guys, and to Rose’s evident dismay. George, abashed by his brother’s bluntness, offers his apologies to Rose, and that’s not all. Reader, he marries her! The upshot is that Rose and Peter move in with George and Phil. The latter, as you might imagine, despises the intrusion; he calls Rose “a cheap schemer” to her face. Campion now has her principal characters where she wants them.

And there they stay. Do not be misled by the setting into construing this movie as a Western. It’s more of a chamber piece with chaps, largely roam-free, and you soon realize that it ain’t going anywhere. Rather, it’s sticking around and digging into the various cruelties and miseries on display, like a surgeon exploring a wound. Rose, humiliated by Phil, and socially out of her depth, takes to drink, her features increasingly ruddied by liquor and tears. (It’s a major role for Dunst, yet so oppressive as almost to grind her down.) George dwindles from view. Phil, for reasons that he chooses to conceal, draws unexpectedly close to Peter, and takes him out riding. Peter, in return, has secret ambitions of his own.

One way to measure “The Power of the Dog” is to lay it beside Elia Kazan’s “East of Eden” (1955)—another saga of fraternal rivalry, laden with Biblical overtones. (Kazan’s leading man, James Dean, reads out the Thirty-second Psalm.) Both films are too inward-turning, and too sombrely shadowed, to count as epics, despite the grandeur of their landscapes. Why, then, in terms of momentum, should “East of Eden” be so much the stronger? Perhaps because of Dean, and the twisted, unslackening, near-laughable grip of his presence; he doesn’t seem to know what he’s going to do next, and the suspense is contagious. Though Cumberbatch, too, can be compelling, and though you constantly wonder what is stored in reserve behind his wintry gaze, he is at heart a master of urbanity, and not everyone will be convinced that he’s truly at home on the range. Still, you should certainly seek out the movie, and relish its central standoff: Rose, downstairs, stumbling through an awkward tune on a piano, versus Phil, plucking away on his banjo, without mercy, in a room overhead. The scene is as tense as the gunfight at the O.K. Corral. Guess who wins.

There are helicopter parents, and then there are tennis parents. Tennis parents are more like the choppers in “Apocalypse Now” (1979), overcoming every little setback with the help of napalm and Wagner. Even among tennis parents, however, few have matched the firepower of Richard Williams, the father of Venus and Serena Williams . He is now the hero of the modestly titled “King Richard,” a new film from Reinaldo Marcus Green, which follows Venus and Serena—played with robust good humor, and stinging forehands, by Saniyya Sidney and Demi Singleton, respectively—from girlhood to the brink of stardom. Yet the movie isn’t really about them. How come?

Because Richard is played by Will Smith . It’s one of Smith’s all-consuming performances. He’s often alone in the frame, and, when other folks do cluster around, he remains the hub of dramatic attention. Hunching his shoulders, lowering his head, and thrusting out his jaw, Smith looks ever-primed for the fray—startlingly so, because we know how loose and gangly he can be. He still gets plenty of laughs, but there’s a militant edge to the comedy. Simple shots of him, at the wheel of an old camper van, show a soul no longer capable of repose. At night, Richard works as a security guard, and carries a weapon; by day, he favors tennis shorts and sneakers. Either way, he’s like a soldier who won’t get out of his uniform. The call to action can come at any time.

Richard and his wife, Brandi (Aunjanue Ellis), live in Compton with their five daughters. I kept hoping to hear the other three girls talk among themselves about Venus and Serena, but no such scene occurs. (Any whisper of disunity would be inimical to the purpose of the film; solidarity is all.) The domestic regime is stern, with obligatory straight A’s at school. Tennis practice continues even in a downpour—volleys and smashes only, since the balls won’t bounce. Now and then, Richard falls foul of local thugs. “Daddy got beat up again,” the girls report, with a sigh. When cops and social services come by to check on the family, Richard responds by commanding his kids to spell the word “civilization.” He declares, “We got future doctors, and lawyers, plus a couple of tennis stars in this house.” For Venus and Serena, he has a particular plan. It runs to seventy-eight pages. He wrote it before they were born.

The movie’s big reveal is withheld until the end credits, in which Venus and Serena Williams are named as executive producers. So much for objectivity. Yet audiences know when they’re being sold something, and they would balk at “King Richard” if it were merely a slab of promotional P.R. As it is, when I saw the film, with a big crowd, you could sense people leaning into the story and feeding off its verve. The atmosphere that is brewed by Green and his director of photography, Robert Elswit, is a blend of the aggressive and the benign. Nothing is more welcoming or more sun-smothered, for example, than the Florida tennis academy to which Venus and Serena are invited by a leading coach, Rick Macci (Jon Bernthal), with their sisters and their parents in tow; no sooner do they arrive, however, than Richard announces that Venus will not be competing on the junior circuit. She will bide her time and then, at his behest, turn pro.

Is there madness in Richard’s method? Unquestionably. Even if he began by deliberately pushing two of his children into a super-white sport, could he honestly have foreseen that they would indeed conquer the field? Surely not. What makes Green’s film so persuasive is that other characters—above all, the redoubtable Brandi Williams—are alive to everything that’s absurd and overbearing, as well as noble, in the hero’s cause. “You are the most stubborn person I’ve met in my life,” one guy says to Richard. “And I coach McEnroe .” ♦

New Yorker Favorites

• How we became infected by chain e-mail .
• Twelve classic movies to watch with your kids.
• The secret lives of fungi .
• The photographer who claimed to capture the ghost of Abraham Lincoln .
• Why are Americans still uncomfortable with atheism ?
• The enduring romance of the night train .
• Sign up for our daily newsletter to receive the best stories from The New Yorker .

The Definitive Voice of Entertainment News

Subscribe for full access to The Hollywood Reporter

site categories

Benedict cumberbatch in jane campion’s ‘the power of the dog’: film review.

Kirsten Dunst, Jesse Plemons and Kodi Smit-McPhee also star in this study of blistering family tensions in the American West, adapted from Thomas Savage's novel.

By David Rooney

David Rooney

Chief Film Critic

• Share on Facebook
• Share to Flipboard
• Send an Email
• Show additional share options
• Share on LinkedIn
• Share on Pinterest
• Share on Reddit
• Share on Tumblr
• Share on Whats App
• Print the Article
• Post a Comment

Twelve years after her last feature, Jane Campion makes a thrilling return with The Power of the Dog , a work as boldly idiosyncratic, unpredictable and alive with psychological complexity as anything in the revered director’s output. For a filmmaker who has predominantly focused on forensic investigations of the female psyche, this riveting adaptation of the 1967 Thomas Savage novel represents an assured thematic shift to corrosive masculinity and repressed sexuality. The intimately uncomfortable drama is a chamber piece on an epic canvas, driven by transfixing performances from Benedict Cumberbatch , Kirsten Dunst , Jesse Plemons and, in a stunning breakout turn, young Australian actor Kodi Smit-McPhee .

Related Stories

Charithra chandran joins 'one piece' season 2 at netflix, 'bojack horseman' creator sets new adult animated comedy at netflix.

Following a festival tour that begins with a Venice competition launch, the film will be released in theaters and on Netflix in the fall.

The Power of the Dog

Venue : Venice Film Festival (Competition) Cast : Benedict Cumberbatch, Kirsten Dunst, Jesse Plemons, Kodi Smit-McPhee, Thomasin McKenzie, Genevieve Lemon, Peter Carroll, Alison Bruce, Keith Carradine, Frances Conroy Director-screenwriter : Jane Campion

Campion has always been an expressive visual filmmaker, getting the most out of collaborations with a number of talented cinematographers. Remote country on New Zealand’s South Island stands in for sparsely populated 1925 Montana in starkly beautiful images captured by DP Ari Wegner ( Zola , True History of the Kelly Gang ), notable for their striking depth of field and the hypnotic play of light over the mountains. Those aspects reward the big-screen experience, though the thorny psychodrama of four people isolated in a sprawling landscape will be equally enthralling to streaming viewers.

Though Campion made the New York City thriller In the Cut and dissected the social mores of Americans in Europe in The Portrait of a Lady , this kind of fine-grained Americana is entirely new to her and will no doubt draw fresh attention to Savage’s mostly forgotten novel. The time and place are superbly evoked in Grant Major’s production design, dominated by a cattle ranch homestead reminiscent of the Sam Shepard character’s in Days of Heaven , only darker and more oppressively Gothic with its heavy oak interiors, surrounded by grassy plains and backed by mountains.

The place is home to wealthy ranchers the Burbank brothers, who could not be less alike. Phil (Cumberbatch), with his coarse vernacular, is a rugged man of the land, coating himself in mud and swimming naked in a secluded river retreat rather than using the house bath, as his gentlemanly brother, George (Plemons), recommends. While Phil is seldom seen in anything but boots and spurs and dirty sheepskin chaps, George is nattily dressed at all times in tweedy three-piece suits and bow ties. (The character-defining costumes are by Kirsty Cameron.) He takes care of the business side of the ranch, leaving the physical labor to Phil and his cowhands.

They still share a bedroom like children, and “Georgie boy” seems almost immune to the sneering taunts of his brother. Any discussion of their citified parents, referred to as the Old Gent (Peter Carroll) and the Old Lady (Frances Conroy), suggests there has never been much love in the family. Only when Phil speaks of “Bronco Henry,” who taught them the ranching trade and died two decades earlier, does he soften into a kind of haunted reverence that takes on deeper meaning as the story progresses.

In a scene of knife-edge tension early on, George, Phil and the latter’s rowdy crew stop for dinner on a market day at the Red Mill, another eye-catching structure of weather-beaten splendor from designer Major that looks like something out of a Walker Evans photograph. While the restaurant’s pianola and its proximity to the local saloon attract drunks and whores, widowed proprietress Rose (Dunst) strives to keep the place respectable, helped only by her sensitive beanpole son, Peter (Smit-McPhee), who waits tables and makes intricate paper flowers to decorate them.

Such signs of gentility in a place that seems hostile to refinement bring out the worst of Phil’s bullying. His cruel mockery of Peter’s perceived effeminate delicacy, played up for the benefit of his adoring cowhands, prompts the young man to retreat into nervous behavioral tics while reducing Rose to tears. George stays behind after the dinner to apologize for his brother and comfort Rose, marking the beginnings of a gentle romance.

Leaning into the material’s literary origins, Campion breaks up the story into five chapters, marked only by Roman numerals. An unspecified amount of time has passed when the third of them begins, and George’s courtship of Rose has proceeded away from the eyes of his mean-spirited brother. Phil is quietly enraged to learn of their marriage only after the fact, when George brings Rose to live at the mansion. Meanwhile, Peter has begun medical school, following in the footsteps of his doctor father, who took his own life. Phil shares his disgust with his brother in a letter to their mother: “Got himself tangled up with a suicide widow and her half-cooked son.”

George, by contrast, visibly lightens up with the introduction of warmth into his life. “I just wanted to say how nice it is not to be alone,” he tells Rose in one of several scenes where the rapport between real-life partners Dunst and Plemons adds lovely authenticity to the depth of feeling between their characters.

Phil’s malicious campaign to make Rose feel unwelcome and undermine her stability begins by openly calling her a “cheap schemer” and proceeds by ridiculing her nervous efforts at the piano George has purchased to surprise his new wife. Plucking out the same piece — Strauss’ “Radetzky March” — on his banjo with greater dexterity, Phil takes pleasure in signs of her unraveling as she begins drinking, hiding bottles of bourbon around the house. He deliberately humiliates her at a dinner George throws for the governor and his wife (Keith Carradine and Alison Bruce), where Rose also meets her visiting parents-in-law for the first time.

The mounting dread embedded in the narrative and enhanced by the increasingly agitated strings of Jonny Greenwood’s atmospheric score — which is right up there with the Radiohead musician’s powerful work on There Will Be Blood — seems to have set the story on an inevitable trajectory toward sorrow. But Campion keeps shifting expectations, even after Peter comes to stay on his summer break, giving Phil a new target for his cunning psychological assaults.

This is where Smit-McPhee’s layered characterization reveals intriguing surprises; the actor’s edgy scenes with Cumberbatch are among the movie’s most nuanced. When Phil takes Peter under his wing, teaching him to ride a horse and braiding a special rope from cowhide strips for him, it seems at first like a tactic to further distress Rose and ridicule her son for sport. But as Peter stumbles onto evidence that provides a window into Phil’s bitterness, the younger man begins to grow more confident around his unlikely mentor.

The queer undercurrents that ripple throughout the drama are most acutely felt in the taut final chapters. You sense clearly that something terrible is destined to happen, but right up until the startling conclusion, the nature of that tragedy remains unclear. Both Cumberbatch and Smit-McPhee feed the ambiguity over whether hardened Phil has opened himself up to genuine affection or is playing a vicious game — and whether Peter, who has more intelligence and human understanding than anyone gives him credit for, has discovered an affinity with the older man or is manipulating him.

This is an exquisitely crafted film, its unhurried rhythms continually shifting as plangent notes of melancholy, solitude, torment, jealousy and resentment surface. Campion is in full control of her material, digging deep into the turbulent inner life of each of her characters with unerring subtlety.

Cumberbatch hasn’t had a role that makes such stimulating use of his unique qualities as an actor in years. His Phil is a darkly charismatic man, more cultured than he cares to show. He’s cold almost to a reptilian degree but damaged and yearning for something beneath his unfeeling exterior, which emerges in the sad sensuality of his scenes alone by the river. Dunst makes Rose as fragile as fine porcelain, adhering to codes of womanhood imprinted on the era; her spiral into alcoholism and paranoia is quite shattering, as is her palpable fear of every interaction with Phil. Plemons’ George is soft-spoken and even-tempered, initially making him seem weak, but there’s strength and integrity in his refusal to descend to his brother’s toxic level even if his inattention to his wife’s unhappiness points to his unfamiliarity with the workings of a loving relationship. And Smit-McPhee is simply extraordinary, maintaining Peter’s mystery until the very end.

Among the supporting cast, Carradine brings indelible associations with the American West to his brief appearance, while Thomasin McKenzie is a lively presence as a young maid, and longtime Campion collaborator Genevieve Lemon (the star of the director’s first feature, Sweetie ) makes the Burbanks’ housekeeper a no-nonsense woman unfazed by her employers’ odd ways.

The title of Savage’s novel comes from Psalm 22:20 in the Bible: “Deliver my soul from the sword; my darling from the power of the dog.” That Old Testament prayer for the protection of loved ones from enemies has clear correlations within the story. But the film’s enigmatic qualities are fueled also by a rock formation in the mountains behind the homestead, which only Phil is able to see, until Peter immediately identifies the outline of a barking dog. That mystical element connects the human drama of these four conflicted people to the landscape itself in ways that echo the classic Western while also providing a bracingly modern take on the genre.

Full credits

Venue: Venice Film Festival (Competition) Cast: Benedict Cumberbatch, Kirsten Dunst, Jesse Plemons, Kodi Smit-McPhee, Thomasin McKenzie, Genevieve Lemon, Peter Carroll, Alison Bruce, Keith Carradine, Frances Conroy Distributor: Netflix Production companies: See-Saw Films, Bad Girl Creek, Max Films Director-screenwriter: Jane Campion Based on the novel by Thomas Savage Producers: Jane Campion, Tanya Seghatchian, Emile Sherman, Iain Canning, Roger Frappier Executive producers: Simons Gillis, Rose Garnett, John Woodward Director of photography: Ari Wegner Production designer: Grant Major Costume designer: Kirsty Cameron Music: Jonny Greenwood Editor: Peter Sciberras Casting: Nikki Barrett, Tina Cleary, Nina Gold

THR Newsletters

Sign up for THR news straight to your inbox every day

More from The Hollywood Reporter

Box office: ‘deadpool & wolverine’ back on top as ‘blink twice’ underwhelms and ‘the crow’ collapses, peter dinklage is optimistic ‘toxic avenger’ reboot will get released and “have its day in the toxic sun”, ‘mission: impossible,’ ‘oppenheimer,’ ‘fallout,’ ‘fargo,’ ‘ripley’ win 2024 location managers guild awards, ryan reynolds on why rob mcelhenney’s ‘deadpool & wolverine’ cameo got cut: “sometimes have to kill your darlings”, how to watch the ‘halloween’ movies in order, denzel washington says “there are very few films left for me to make that i’m interested in”.

• Search Please fill out this field.
• Newsletters
• Sweepstakes
• Movie Reviews

The Power of the Dog review: Jane Campion delivers a tricky, arresting neo-noir Western

It's easy enough to describe how The Power of the Dog begins: with two Montana ranchers on a cattle run, somewhere in the vast American outback of the early 20th century. But the whole of Jane Campion 's sparse, bristling Western noir (in select theaters Nov. 17, on Netflix Dec. 1) can't really be seen or understood until the last thunderclap frame.

The 120 minutes or so that pass in between play like a kind of master class in sustained dread, sublimated feeling, and toxic masculinity. The earliest scenes come on slow and strange, tone-wise, consumed mostly with the prickly introduction of brothers Phil ( Benedict Cumberbatch ) and George ( Jesse Plemons ), whose relationship seems based at best on grim tolerance: Phil, in his dusty chaps and battered hat, embodies the lone-cowboy ideal, or at least certainly fancies himself that way. George is quieter but demonstrably kinder (Phil calls him Fatso regularly), a gentle, bulky man with no particular affinity for life on the range.

A pit stop for food and rest with the men in their crew leads to a boarding house run by the widowed Rose ( Kirsten Dunst ) and her teenage son, Peter ( Kodi Smit-McPhee ). Phil picks up immediately on Peter's vulnerabilities — the boy has placed handmade paper flowers on every table, and speaks with a telltale lisp — and runs with them, a bully a who loves nothing better than a target and an audience. But his malice backfires, drawing George closer to Rose; within days or weeks (the story's division into chapters never quite establishes a firm timeline) the pair are married, and the fragile, sad-eyed Rose becomes lady of the ranch.

Her hopeful overtures of goodwill to Phil are quickly sunk ("You're a cheap schemer," he snarls dismissively), and her loneliness is only alleviated, increasingly, by alcohol: in the linen cupboard, under the bedcovers, down by the side of the house. No one ever speaks about the past (or anything, really) unless they have to, though small clues slither out — like the fact that Phil has a classics degree from Yale concealed somewhere under his saddle, even if he vastly prefers to knot rope and castrate steer and sneer at the dinner table. But Peter's arrival at the ranch between school terms upsets the teetering equilibrium of their already unhappy home.

Campion, the celebrated director of singular dramas like The Piano and An Angel at My Table , hasn't made a movie in more than a decade (though she did helm the unnerving 2013 miniseries Top of the Lake and its 2017 follow-up), and Power of the Dog feels like the product of a long gestation, forged in endlessly peelable layers of suggestion and subtext. The dialogue is sparse and the scenery obscenely beautiful, the wide-open vistas of her native New Zealand standing in for circa-1925 Montana. Cumberbatch at first feels like he might have been miscast — too intrinsically British and cerebral for the cruel Marlboro Man swagger of his character. But as he and Smit-McPhee begin to circle one another, the odd thrumming chemistry between the actors clicks in in a way that feels almost inevitable.

Maybe because she comes from a country that famously holds more sheep than people , Campion has always seemed to be particularly attuned to the natural world — a horse's rippling flanks, a bend in a river, blood glistening on golden stalks of wheat — and for exploring the soft animal that lives inside most humans beneath their thin layers of clothing and civility. (She also, incidentally, continues her one-woman fight as an equalizer of male nudity on screen here.) Power of the Dog is in no rush to show its hand, and the film can feel almost willfully obtuse in its pacing and plot. Unless you're one of the few who's read Thomas Savage's 1967 book of the same name on which the script is based, there's rarely a moment that doesn't feel racked with the queasy, thrilling promise of sudden violence or epiphany. Pinning down the cumulative effect of Campion's slow-drip storytelling is trickier, except to say that being submerged in her ineffable world feels not just like two hours in the dark, but high art. Grade: A-

Related content:

• King Richard review: Will Smith rules in tennis biopic
• Dune review: Denis Villeneuve's starry sci-fi epic is breathtaking, and a little bit maddening
• The French Dispatch review: Wes Anderson as his most Wes Anderson-y

Related Articles

Kodi Smit-McPhee walks us through that ‘Power of the Dog’ ending

• Copy Link URL Copied!

Spoiler warning: The following interview discusses key details of Netflix’s “The Power of the Dog,” including the ending. If you haven’t yet seen the film, come back when you have, and check out our review , profile of director Jane Campion and interview with co-star Kirsten Dunst .

Five minutes into “The Power of the Dog,” we meet Peter (Kodi Smit-McPhee), a frail-looking young man sitting alone in his room, painstakingly crafting paper flowers that will be placed as table centerpieces in the restaurant inn that his mother, Rose (Kirsten Dunst), owns.

Later that evening, those flowers will turn to ash, burned by the bullying cattle rancher Phil (Benedict Cumberbatch), the first in a series of threatening acts directed toward Peter and his mother, menace that gives Jane Campion’s chamber piece western a mounting, almost unbearable tension — which Smit-McPhee felt acutely when first reading the script.

“I felt sorry for Peter the whole time,” Smit-McPhee, 25, says during a recent conversation at a Santa Monica restaurant. “I had so many judgments about the way he carried himself. Eventually those judgments solidified and I just had this sense of impending doom coming toward him.”

And then we come to understand that perhaps we weren’t seeing Peter clearly.

Smit-McPhee is right there with us. When he reached the end of his first pass through the script, he flipped back a few pages to make sure he hadn’t missed anything.

“I didn’t miss anything,” the intense Australian actor says, smiling.

If you’ve seen “The Power of the Dog” — and, again, if you haven’t, bookmark this page for later reading — you might be wondering if you missed anything too. Smit-McPhee, a newly minted New York Film Critics Circle supporting actor winner, is here to answer all your questions, from the reasons behind Peter’s choice of footwear to the movie’s astonishing ending.

Review: ‘Power of the Dog’ reasserts Jane Campion’s mastery and reveals a new side of Benedict Cumberbatch

Kirsten Dunst, Jesse Plemons and Kodi Smit-McPhee co-star in this superlative Netflix adaptation of Thomas Savage’s novel.

Nov. 16, 2021

When does Peter decide to murder Phil?

It’s ambiguous, so this is just me ... but I think it’s when he sees him burn the flowers.

It goes all the way back to the flowers? I thought it was prompted by seeing his mother descend into alcoholism, thanks to Phil’s cruelty.

Sure. But Phil’s certainly on Peter’s radar from that first night. It’s a beautiful metaphor. Phil’s burning roses, which he is about to do to Peter’s mother, destroying her. But I think Peter’s also upset that Phil brought him almost to the point of crying on that first encounter. He didn’t know he could get hurt that easily.

Yes, Peter goes outside and we see him spinning the hula hoop, which I initially saw as a coping mechanism, like those fidget spinners that were so popular a few years ago.

It looks like he’s trying to soothe his anxiety. It feels like he’s lost control. But it’s quite the opposite. He is managing. He is absolutely in control.

Jane Campion explains her enigmatic career choices: ‘I’m careful about the bones I care to chew on’

With Netflix’s “The Power of the Dog,” Jane Campion is enjoying her most celebrated film in years. And the long journey makes it all the sweeter.

Dec. 1, 2021

Same with him running his fingers across the teeth of the comb, which we see him doing during times of apparent stress. The initial impression is he’s trying to cope ... or annoy his mother. Or both!

You know, doing that with the comb calmed me down when playing him. But I think for Peter, it’s a way of managing his thoughts and emotions. It’s a physical manifestation of the way his mind works, sparking off different thoughts and plans. Same with the hula hoop. Go back and watch it and I don’t think you’ll ever see someone spin a hula hoop with that much anger.

OK. So you think Peter always planned to kill Phil and when he learns about the calves dying from anthrax, that tidbit sparks the idea to put the plan into action?

Cutting the anthrax out of the cow, much like killing the rabbit in his room, is partly fulfilling his ambition toward becoming a doctor. But Peter is an improviser. He goes with the flow. And when he sees that Phil has nicked his hand, that gives him the idea to contaminate the rawhide and infect him.

Peter is constantly assessing, waiting for the perfect moment to strike. I guess that’s in the nature of many animals, but for Peter, I chose the fox to assimilate his character with. They’re so light on their feet and they’re pretty and they look delicate and sweet. And yet they can tiptoe up to a hole and pounce right in and you’re a goner.

Which brings us to the scene in the barn where Peter infects Phil with the anthrax. It’s such a delicate dance between these two men, and dare I say ...

You felt bad for Phil? I’m right there with you. Phil’s walls, the walls that have solidified for so long, are gone and his mask is removed. We learn the truth about his love for Bronco Henry. And, yes, he may have been groomed, but I think what he had with Bronco Henry was genuine. He was in love. And he had to hide that from the world. Whereas Peter ... Phil envies Peter because he can completely be himself. It’s interesting how they swap roles. Peter becomes the darker, crueler figure and Phil the more innocent child with a great deal of trauma. When Peter’s holding the contaminated rope with his gloves on, I believe he’s thinking about Phil. And it hurts.

Do you think Peter ever considered scrapping his plan and sparing Phil?

No. It was the same thing with the rabbit he killed so he could dissect it. He’s going to do what he has to do. And even though for Peter this might possibly his first interaction with intimacy or love for another person, he’s willing to sacrifice that for his mother.

For Kirsten Dunst, ‘Power of the Dog’ was an opportunity to ‘let it all hang out’

Kirsten Dunst discusses her dream of working with Jane Campion, acting opposite her partner Jesse Plemons and surviving depression.

Nov. 28, 2021

You mentioning Phil envying Peter because he’s so self-possessed reminded me of Peter’s white shoes. They look so out of place on the ranch ... which, again, is a bit of misdirection, isn’t it?

Yes! The shoes symbolize Peter’s confidence and his unwavering spirit in the face of judgment. He likes those shoes, and he doesn’t care if you don’t. And I love that after he kills Phil, he puts away the cowboy boots and the hat and slips on the tennis shoes again. He jumps right back into who he is and who he always was.

Who do you think Peter is in 10 years?

A lot of us have that question. Norman Bates, possibly, in “Psycho”?

He’s running a hotel with Rose’s skeleton in a rocking chair upstairs?

I think he just became an acclaimed doctor. Very good at his job. And I think it’s even more fascinating that this just becomes one of the stories of his past and no one ever finds out. He goes out and does exactly what he wanted to do, which is to become a good doctor, like his father was. That’s how much more eerie. Killing Phil was just something he had to do, and now he’s gone on with his life. Probably still wearing those white tennis shoes.

Entertainment & Arts

7 movies by Jane Campion to stream after you finish ‘The Power of the Dog’

In Screen Gab No. 15, we discuss a disappointing season of ‘Selling Sunset,’ draw up a guide to Jane Campion’s movies and say goodbye to ‘PEN15.’

Dec. 3, 2021

More to Read

For ‘Chimp Crazy’ director Eric Goode, ‘the end justifies the means’

Aug. 25, 2024

Sad to see the end of ‘Reservation Dogs’? It had to happen now, says its creator

Aug. 12, 2024

Sterlin Harjo on legacy of ‘Reservation Dogs’ and its Emmy nods: ‘People crave different stories’

July 17, 2024

Only good movies

Get the Indie Focus newsletter, Mark Olsen's weekly guide to the world of cinema.

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.

Glenn Whipp covers film and television for the Los Angeles Times and serves as columnist for The Envelope, The Times’ awards season publication.

More From the Los Angeles Times

Michael Madsen’s wife ‘broke into’ Malibu home, actor won’t be charged after arrest, lawyer says

Aug. 23, 2024

Review: ‘The Killer’ brings a Hong Kong action genius back to the site of his own crimes

Review: A cantor and an older student find reciprocity in the playful ‘Between the Temples’

Review: Weighed down by too much muck and not enough myth, a slackly remade ‘The Crow’ flops

'The Power of the Dog' review: Benedict Cumberbatch stuns as a cruel cowboy in Jane Campion film

The period drama “The Power of the Dog” is a picturesque, enthralling exploration of male ego and toxic masculinity, crafted by an extremely talented woman and offering enough nuanced bite to keep it interesting till the very end. The film led Oscar nominations Tuesday, scoring 12 nods including best picture , best director and three acting nods. 

Amazingly directed by Jane Campion (“The Piano”), the adaptation of the 1967 Thomas Savage novel unbridles Benedict Cumberbatch for a career-best performance as a boorish and bullying cowboy alongside strong turns from Kirsten Dunst and Jesse Plemons, plus a standout showing by Kodi Smit-McPhee. “Power of the Dog” (★★★½ out of four; rated R; streaming on Netflix) also gives new perspective on the Western genre, with plenty of dudes on horses but also a powerful intimacy.

'The Power of the Dog': Kirsten Dunst wanted to play 'a really strong woman'

Set in 1925 Montana, the narrative centers on ranching brothers who couldn’t be more opposite: George Burbank (Plemons) is the quiet and kind business side of the duo, Phil (Cumberbatch) is the volatile sibling with the brusque attitude and endless machismo who is either adored or despised. A cattle drive finds them dining at a restaurant owned by widow Rose (Dunst). Phil has a big time making fun of the lisp and effeminate demeanor of Rose’s waiter son Peter (Smit-McPhee), an artistic and reserved lad who makes paper flowers for the tables. Rose is sad and appalled by Phil’s antics, but falls for George’s hearty gentleman nature.

Oscar nominations 2022: 'The Power of the Dog' leads with 12, Kristen Stewart nabs first nod

Oscar snubs: These stars missed out on 2022 Oscar nominations

They get married and Rose moves into the brothers’ house, sending Phil’s bad behavior to a new level of mean. That in addition to George’s pressure on her to impress at social functions drives her to drink. When Peter comes home from college for the summer, Phil is at first mocking yet slowly takes the youth under his wing and finds a connection. Much to Rose’s horror, Phil wants to teach Peter the cowboy way in the same fashion that Phil’s beloved mentor, Bronco Henry, did for him.

Snubbed!  Ben Affleck, Jennifer Hudson, Lady Gaga, Leonardo DiCaprio miss out on Oscar nominations

Campion’s film captures gorgeous imagery of a sprawling wide-open landscape and detailed natural settings that act as a splendid background for all the human dynamics at work. Everybody hides a part of themselves from the others, there’s an extraordinarily thin line between love and hate, and Campion plays these personalities out onscreen like a master fiddler.

Cumberbatch is known for the breadth of roles on his impressive resume, from real-life math genius Alan Turing in “The Imitation Game” to Marvel’s superhero sorcerer Doctor Strange, but Phil gives him all he can chew on and more. An absolutely ornery son of a gun, Cumberbatch’s character lives to belittle his brother (often calling him "Fatso"), rouse his usually shirtless ranch hands and vex his new sister-in-law, be it through harsh words or hot licks on his banjo. Yet the actor also delivers on the complicated internal side of the role, as Phil’s insecurities, secrets and desires reveal themselves to show the humanity underneath that leathery exterior.

11 can't-miss films by women directors:  From 'Bruised' to 'The Power of the Dog'

Dunst and Plemons, a couple in real life, bring their chemistry to the screen, with Dunst especially delving deep as the tortured Rose. But as much Oscar consideration as Cumberbatch and of course Campion will gin up, Smit-McPhee deserves his kudos for a wondrous breakthrough: Peter might be the meek youngster who studies a lot, yet his perspective is the most intriguing of the bunch.

“The Power of the Dog” is a Western epic that revels in deconstructing the cowboy mythos and leaves its most jarring surprise for its denouement. Campion masterfully knocks you out of the saddle but this ride is so good, you’ll hardly complain when getting back up again.

• Election 2024
• Entertainment
• Newsletters
• Photography
• AP Buyline Personal Finance
• AP Buyline Shopping
• Press Releases
• Israel-Hamas War
• Russia-Ukraine War
• Global elections
• Asia Pacific
• Latin America
• Middle East
• Delegate Tracker
• AP & Elections
• College football
• Auto Racing
• Movie reviews
• Book reviews
• Financial Markets
• Business Highlights
• Financial wellness
• Artificial Intelligence
• Social Media

Review: ‘The Power of the Dog’ is a sublime gothic Western

This image released by Netflix shows Benedict Cumberbatch in a scene from “The Power of the Dog” (Netflix via AP)

This image released by Netflix shows Kodi Smit-McPhee in a scene from “The Power of the Dog” (Netflix via AP)

This image released by Netflix shows Kirsten Dunst in a scene from “The Power of the Dog” (Netflix via AP)

This image released by Netflix shows Jesse Plemons, left, and Kirsten Dunst in a scene from “The Power of the Dog” (Netflix via AP)

This image released by Netflix shows Benedict Cumberbatch, left, and Jesse Plemons in a scene from “The Power of the Dog.” (Kirsty Griffin/Netflix via AP)

This image released by Netflix shows Benedict Cumberbatch in a scene from “The Power of the Dog.” (Kirsty Griffin/Netflix via AP)

This image released by Netflix shows Kodi Smit-McPhee in a scene from “The Power of the Dog” (Kirsty Griffin/Netflix via AP)

• Copy Link copied

Tracking shots of a solitary figure striding across a Western plain, seen from within the darkened interiors of a home, bookend Jane Campion’s “The Power of the Dog.” As the man walks, with wrinkled foothills behind him, the camera glides through the house. He goes into and out of view with each window.

The man is Phil Burbank (Benedict Cumberbatch), a rough-hewn Montana rancher with a menacing arrogance and a cocky, upright posture. The first time we see him this way, through the windows, it’s an early signal that “The Power of the Dog” will pulsate with friction between within and without, that its masterful vision of the West will play out in a juxtaposition of rugged exteriors and murkier, more mysterious interiors.

“The Power of the Dog” is Campion’s first film since her luminous 2009 John Keats drama “Bright Star"; in the interim she made the series “Top of the Lake,” the vivid New Zealand mystery. Even without stepping on a film set in 12 years, though, appreciation for Campion has grown. Her films, including her 1993 masterwork “The Piano,” have only gained admirers for the way they capture assertive inner lives piercing social structures and male hegemony. In Campion’s formally composed films, lyricism claws its way through.

Adapted by Campion from Thomas Savage’s 1967 novel, “The Power of the Dog” is less a return to form for Campion than a big-screen reminder of her virtuosity. The film, which Netflix opened in theaters Wednesday, isn’t the Western you might think it is — though it does reside on the frontier. (Campion shot New Zealand for 1920s Montana, and its foreign, craggy mountain contours only enhance the feeling that this is not your traditional Old West.) There is Jonny Greenwood’s disquieting score, for starters. And the foreboding, oversized ranch house, a hulking wooden pile on dry grasslands, is also a hint that something more gothic is at play here.

There lives Phil and brother George (Jesse Plemons), a study in opposites. George is finely dressed, humble and decorous; Phil, while a studied intellect, seems to never take off his chaps. He revels in the outdoor life of the range. “I stink, and I like it,” he says. Phil is confident he holds a greater understanding of farm life, masculinity and something more existential. He sees something in the folds of the looming mountain range that his men struggle to identify. One asks if there’s something there. “Not if you can’t see it, there ain’t,” Phil replies.

But just what Phil can and can’t see is at the heart of “The Power of the Dog,” a film that, like the novel, takes its name from a Psalm. The full line goes: “Deliver my soul from the sword, my darling from the power of the dog.” Dogs, seen in Biblical times as unclean scavengers, were a kind of stand-in for the devil. But whose soul is in jeopardy in “The Power of the Dog”?

It would seem very much that Rose Gordon (Kirsten Dunst, brilliant) is the one in the crosshairs. She’s a widow running a boarding house whom George falls for and quickly marries. (Their romance, which Campion allows one sweeping shot of as they embrace with a cathedral of mountain peaks all around, has a special sweetness in that it’s a real-life one, too.) When George brings her home, Phil isn’t shy about his unhappiness in the intrusion of a woman into his manly realm. Though his brother has long ago learned to avoid or ignore Phil’s fearsome glare, Rose begins to wilt under the pressure and starts drinking heavily. A psychodrama sets in, only where the movie goes from here isn’t as obvious as you might think.

The three’s-a-crowd tension doesn’t subside, but Campion’s film steadily gravitates to a fourth character: Rose’s teenage son, Peter (Kodi Smit-McPhee). He comes to the ranch only in the movie’s second act, introducing an entirely different, maybe modern presence to the drama. Peter is a slender beanpole who dresses in black and white and — gasp — sneakers, and crafts fragile flowers out of paper. Phil, who conceals his homosexuality, takes Peter under his wing, an almost unfathomable development poised somewhere between horror (that Phil’s hard lessons will only set up the seemingly delicate Peter for slaughter) and tenderness. Cumberbatch, so alive to his character’s contradictions, and Smit-McPhee, with a bracingly singular demeanor and a sly strength, artfully play both possibilities.

Against a grand backdrop, “The Power of the Dog” fluctuates with evolving power dynamics that seem to almost seize the movie, itself. Campion’s film can feel unbalanced, with its primary characters often paired or isolated but seldom all together despite the chamber piece set-up. (George especially fades from view.) And as richly drawn as the movie is, the ending comes almost too quick. “The Power of the Dog” may in the end be more a twisty psychological thriller than a transcendent frontier epic. But the film’s shape-shifting transformation is also part of its ruthless finesse.

“The Power of the Dog,” a Netflix release, is rated R by the Motion Picture Association of America for brief sexual content/full nudity. Running time: 126 minutes. Three and a half stars out of four.

Follow AP Film Writer Jake Coyle on Twitter at: http://twitter.com/jakecoyleAP

Log in or sign up for Rotten Tomatoes

Trouble logging in?

By continuing, you agree to the Privacy Policy and the Terms and Policies , and to receive email from the Fandango Media Brands .

By creating an account, you agree to the Privacy Policy and the Terms and Policies , and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes and to receive email from the Fandango Media Brands .

By creating an account, you agree to the Privacy Policy and the Terms and Policies , and to receive email from Rotten Tomatoes.

Email not verified

Let's keep in touch.

Sign up for the Rotten Tomatoes newsletter to get weekly updates on:

• Upcoming Movies and TV shows
• Rotten Tomatoes Podcast
• Media News + More

By clicking "Sign Me Up," you are agreeing to receive occasional emails and communications from Fandango Media (Fandango, Vudu, and Rotten Tomatoes) and consenting to Fandango's Privacy Policy and Terms and Policies . Please allow 10 business days for your account to reflect your preferences.

OK, got it!

• About Rotten Tomatoes®
• Login/signup

Movies in theaters

• Opening this week
• Top box office
• Coming soon to theaters
• Certified fresh movies

Movies at home

• Fandango at Home
• Prime Video
• Most Popular Streaming Movies
• Certified Fresh Movies
• What to Watch New

Certified fresh picks

• 77% Blink Twice Link to Blink Twice
• 96% Strange Darling Link to Strange Darling
• 86% Between the Temples Link to Between the Temples

New TV Tonight

• -- The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power: Season 2
• -- Only Murders in the Building: Season 4
• -- Kaos: Season 1
• -- City of God: The Fight Rages On: Season 1
• -- Here Come the Irish: Season 1
• -- Terminator Zero: Season 1
• -- Horror's Greatest: Season 1
• -- After Baywatch: Moment in the Sun: Season 1

Most Popular TV on RT

• 92% Bad Monkey: Season 1
• 100% Dark Winds: Season 2
• 100% Pachinko: Season 2
• 78% Star Wars: The Acolyte: Season 1
• 86% Average Joe: Season 1
• 33% The Accident: Season 1
• 77% Lady in the Lake: Season 1
• 96% Industry: Season 3
• Best TV Shows
• Most Popular TV
• TV & Streaming News

Certified fresh pick

• 100% Pachinko: Season 2 Link to Pachinko: Season 2
• All-Time Lists
• Binge Guide
• Comics on TV
• Five Favorite Films
• Video Interviews
• Weekend Box Office
• Weekly Ketchup
• What to Watch

Box Office 2024: Top 10 Movies of the Year

The Crow Movies, Ranked by Tomatometer

What to Watch: In Theaters and On Streaming

Awards Tour

Poll: Vote for Your Most Anticipated TV or Streaming Show of September

Poll: Vote for Your Most Anticipated Movie of September

• Trending on RT
• Verified Hot Movies
• Re-Release Calendar
• Worst Sequels
• Fall TV First Look

The Power of the Dog Reviews

The Power of the Dog is a film of uncanny beauty and subtle power, whose biggest asset is the curious interplay of contrasts of all kinds: physical power vs. powers of intellect, innocence vs. corruption, honesty vs. hypocrisy, and love vs. hate.

Full Review | Original Score: 4.5/5 | Jul 18, 2024

Not since Lady Macbeth (2016) has a film shifted power dynamics by exploring gender, class, and sexuality in each scene.

Full Review | Jun 10, 2024

Much has already been said about Jane Campion's western masterpiece, and for good reason. It is indeed truly great. Benedict Cumberbatch gives a career best performance.

Full Review | Feb 24, 2024

...as tense and evocative as any horror movie.

Full Review | Jul 28, 2023

An Incredible Movie with Incredible Performances

Full Review | Jul 26, 2023

The Power of the Dog is a thought-provoking, deep study of (toxic) masculinity surrounded by exceptional performances and truly stunning cinematography.

Full Review | Original Score: B+ | Jul 25, 2023

When The Power of the Dog ends, there is an immense desire to immediately start it from the beginning to see the puzzle pieces that were laid out for the audience. To appreciate the movie in a new way, from a bird’s-eye view, knowing how it ends.

Full Review | Jul 25, 2023

‘The Power of the Dog’ is emotional and complex, as the movie shows the meaning of masculinity in the American Western, and how terrifying it is.

Full Review | Original Score: 4.5/5 | Jul 21, 2023

This unique western has a slow pace that works because it is so intentional and essential to the direction of the plot.

Full Review | May 2, 2023

A master class in tension and survival tactics, The Power of the Dog is a film to soak up then meditate over.

Full Review | Mar 31, 2023

Campion’s new Western shares a visual vocabulary with Brokeback Mountain, but what looks like an unlikely love story turns out to be a tale of revenge.

Full Review | Mar 27, 2023

Each of them is a victim of patriarchal policing and patriarchal violence, and each of them perpetuates it, passing that diseased rope around like a noose.

Full Review | Mar 22, 2023

Benedict Cumberbatch gives his best performance to date as the soft speaking, intimidating rancher...

Full Review | Feb 14, 2023

The Power of the Dog will challenge its viewers. If that challenge is accepted, Jane Campion rewards cinephiles with a film that submerges you into its complex characters and themes and is one of the best films of the year.

Full Review | Original Score: 3.5/4 | Jan 31, 2023

What’s so invigorating about this dynamic is that it avoids the easy theory that the homophobe is just gay himself. Instead, The Power of the Dog casually observes that anyone can be both a monster and a victim.

Full Review | Nov 2, 2022

The Power of the Dog explores how societal oppression has the unintended consequence of turning marginalized into oppressors with striking results and a rousing visual narrative.

Full Review | Original Score: 4.5/5 | Oct 21, 2022

Campion’s work is so well-calibrated to the point where the sickening end of one character’s arc feels inevitable, while the hopeful conclusion for others feels tainted with an acidic air despite the promise of a better future.

Full Review | Original Score: A- | Sep 22, 2022

Jane Campion's first film in over a decade is a Western in which the only terse standoff involves its opponents trading musical notes instead of gunfire and the central cowboy duel is one that sees him wrestle with his conflicting emotions.

Full Review | Aug 27, 2022

With The Power of the Dog, Campion is at the height of her skills trotting into her latest mesmerising musing on strength, desire and isolation.

Full Review | Aug 13, 2022

A psychodrama that cleverly writes over the masculine myths and the cowboy cults which have dyed the fabric of American civilisation. Poking plenty of holes in it, Campion tells a story about desire and denial.

Full Review | Aug 8, 2022

UK Edition Change

• UK Politics
• News Videos
• Paris 2024 Olympics
• Rugby Union
• Sport Videos
• John Rentoul
• Mary Dejevsky
• Andrew Grice
• Sean O’Grady
• Photography
• Theatre & Dance
• Culture Videos
• Fitness & Wellbeing
• Food & Drink
• Health & Families
• Royal Family
• Electric Vehicles
• Car Insurance Deals
• Lifestyle Videos
• UK Hotel Reviews
• News & Advice
• Simon Calder
• Australia & New Zealand
• South America
• C. America & Caribbean
• Middle East
• Politics Explained
• News Analysis
• Today’s Edition
• Home & Garden
• Broadband deals
• Fashion & Beauty
• Travel & Outdoors
• Sports & Fitness
• Climate 100
• Sustainable Living
• Climate Videos
• Solar Panels
• Behind The Headlines
• On The Ground
• Decomplicated
• You Ask The Questions
• Binge Watch
• Travel Smart
• Watch on your TV
• Crosswords & Puzzles
• Most Commented
• Newsletters
• Ask Me Anything
• Virtual Events
• Wine Offers
• Betting Sites

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in Please refresh your browser to be logged in

The Power of the Dog review: Benedict Cumberbatch gives one of his finest performances in this subtle, surprising film

In jane campion’s new cowboy thriller, nobody is at all at ease in their own skin, article bookmarked.

Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile

Get our free weekly email for all the latest cinematic news from our film critic Clarisse Loughrey

Get our the life cinematic email for free, thanks for signing up to the the life cinematic email.

Dir: Jane Campion . Starring Benedict Cumberbatch , Kirsten Dunst , Jesse Plemons , Kodi Smit-McPhee. Cert 12A, 127 minutes

Benedict Cumberbatch re-confirms his chameleon-like qualities, giving one of his finest screen performances yet in a very unlikely role in Jane Campion’s new Netflix-backed film, The Power of the Dog . The ever-versatile British actor here plays Phil, a rugged, brutal, dirt-encrusted American cowboy who wears boots with big stirrups and never washes. “I stink and I like it,” he declares at one stage.

The deeply layered film, adapted from Thomas Savage’s novel, is set in the early 20th century. Phil runs a ranch with his brother George (Jesse Plemons). The siblings are close but Phil is appalled at George’s decision to woo and wed Rose (Kirsten Dunst), a widowed former cinema pianist. “If it’s a piece of ass you’re after, I’m damn sure you can get it without a licence,” he sneers. Even worse in his eyes than Rose is her gawky, effeminate young adult son, Peter (Kodi Smit-McPhee). Phil taunts the boy relentlessly and encourages the ranch hands to do the same.

This is a very sly and deceptive affair. It starts like an old Howard Hawks western but, as it deals with repression and yearning, edges ever closer to the world of Campion’s earlier, New Zealand-set period piece, The Piano, or even of Brokeback Mountain . In most cowboy films, the protagonists are one-dimensional, but none of the characters here ever behave in the way you anticipate they will.

Phil doesn’t speak so much as grunt and rarely uses words of more than one syllable. However, he is far better educated than he lets on. Dunst’s Rose seems like one of those strong-willed frontier women who can withstand any misfortune but has hidden frailties. Peter is a sensitive and artistic adolescent who paints beautifully and whose ambition is to become a doctor, but he is also cunning and sometimes very cruel.

There are many deliberately jarring moments. Dunst, the star of Working Title romcom Wimbledon earlier in her career, gets to play one of the stranger games of tennis in recent cinema history. The Jonny Greenwood musical score adds to the edgy atmosphere. Nobody here is at all at ease in their own skin. Campion is exploring different types of male behaviour and finding most of them very wanting. George craves respectability. He wants to lead a tidy, ordered middle-class life. Phil, meanwhile, behaves in absurdly macho and boorish fashion because he is terrified of what he will discover if he looks too far inside himself.

At times, the storytelling is so nuanced that the film threatens to stall. As a viewer, you want the catharsis of a gunfight or a saloon bar brawl. Campion, though, deliberately avoids big dramatic set pieces. She is dealing with violence and sexual longing but in a very subtle and oblique way. All the characters’ feelings here are very deeply sublimated. The fascination of The Power of the Dog lies in its ambiguity and its depth of characterisation. Nothing is obvious here, not even the title.

The Power of the Dog’ is released on Netflix on 1 December

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article

Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.

New to The Independent?

Or if you would prefer:

Hi {{indy.fullName}}

• My Independent Premium
• Account details
• Help centre

Screen Rant

Why the power of the dog's reviews are so positive.

Your changes have been saved

Email is sent

Email has already been sent

Please verify your email address.

You’ve reached your account maximum for followed topics.

Mandalorian Movie Footage Reveals One Subtle Grogu Change With Massive Implications

"exactly the same ending": alien: romulus director confirms similarities with another horror remake, inside out 2: the heartwarming bing bong easter egg explained (& where to spot it).

Jane Campion's  The Power of the Dog has had a great run since it first premiered at the 78th Venice International Film Festival in September 2021. Nominated for 12 Oscars in total,  The Power of the Dog ultimately won Best Director for Jane Campion, who made history in 2022 for being the first woman nominated twice for that particular Academy Award. Clearly,  The Power of the Dog  has enjoyed success at the popular and critical levels, with a Certified Fresh ranking on Rotten Tomatoes.

Set in 1925 Montana, The Power of the Dog follows wealthy ranch owners Phil ( Benedict Cumberbatch ) and George Burbank (Jesse Plemons). Phil is a charismatic rancher who inspires fear and awe in those around him, but when George brings home a new wife, Rose (Kristen Dunst), and her son, Peter (Kodi Smit-McPhee), Phil torments them until he finds himself exposed to the possibility of love, while those around them struggle with their own demons.

Related:  How Did Phil Die In Power Of The Dog?

The Power of the Dog got a limited theatrical release in different countries before arriving on Netflix on December 1, 2021, and it quickly garnered plenty of praise from critics. Currently,  The Power of the Dog has a 93% score on Rotten Tomatoes based on 338 reviews. What critics tend to point out as the strengths of The Power of the Dog are the story’s pace , Campion's direction, and the cast’s performances that project the story’s sense of melancholy and solitude. Here’s what some of the positive reviews of The Power of the Dog  have to say:

“Cinematographer Ari Wegner captures the vistas of Campion’s native New Zealand, doubling as Montana, in lucid, breathtaking detail, while Jonny Greenwood continues his journey as a maverick composer, bookending the narrative with scuffed, low guitar notes and sorrowful strings. Cumberbatch is at his peak here. This is the first time that Campion has presented her filmmaking through a male perspective, and with all of Phil’s flaws and foul nature, the actor is completely engaging.”

“The dialogue is sparse and the scenery obscenely beautiful, the wide-open vistas of her native New Zealand standing in for circa-1925 Montana. Cumberbatch at first feels like he might have been miscast — too intrinsically British and cerebral for the cruel Marlboro Man swagger of his character. But as he and Smit-McPhee begin to circle one another, the odd thrumming chemistry between the actors clicks in in a way that feels almost inevitable.”

Screen Rant :

“Campion’s film is subtle, deeply layered in its approach to both men, their views of each other, and what it really means to be a masculine figure in society. To that end, The Power of the Dog provides a measured, profound analysis of its characters and subject matter.”

“With Smit-McPhee’s Pete, Campion bets on his immutable poker face; the young actor is terrifyingly remarkable. [...] A formidable Dunst, also making her grand re-entrance into cinema after a few years away, melts into the part of a woman weakened by harassment and driven to alcoholism. [...] Cumberbatch wrangles an earth-shattering performance, perhaps his best ever, with an excessive bravado that seems to consume Phil from within.”

The AV Club :

“Although he’s playing a character who’s feared by everyone around him, Cumberbatch refrains from showy outbursts, opting instead to convey Phil’s rigid worldview through stiff posture, hateful words, and an intense, beady stare. Dunst hides Rose’s despair until she can’t anymore, fear and sadness tumbling out of her as she drunkenly stumbles barefoot across the ranch yard wearing nothing but a slip. [...] Smit-McPhee’s sensitive, scholarly Peter similarly contains turbulent inner depths, as we learn when a pet rabbit becomes a dissection model for the aspiring physician.”

Not all praise goes to the performances of the cast of The Power of the Dog – Ari Wegner’s cinematography has also been pointed out as one of the best elements of the movie and with good reason. The scenarios (in this case, those of New Zealand posing as Montana) are key in telling a Western story, and it’s no exception in The Power of the Dog , as they bring more power and also a sense of loneliness to the stories of Phil, Rose, Peter, and George. Although The Power of the Dog 's cast delivers strong performances all around, some critics have highlighted the lack of screen time of Jesse Plemons’ George and Kirsten Dunst’s Rose as a weakness. Likewise, the pace of  The Power of the Dog 's final act (and the movie in general) received some critique for being too slow. For many, however, these factors weren't a problem at all. Here’s what some of the negative reviews of The Power of the Dog have to say:

Discussing Film :

“The core problem lies in the film’s largely lackluster story. Surely, this narrative could have been retooled to be more engaging. The Power of the Dog starts slow and never really picks up, in spite of its all-around promising cast and crew. Additionally, due to this, the film starts to come across as dull. It flutters back and forth over the line of boredom as it occasionally reignites the spectator’s attention”

Midwest Film Journal :

“Frustratingly straightforward and shallow, it is the sort of film that requires the audience to bring a lot more insight and thought than the movie itself is willing to provide.”

Film Inquiry :

It was always expected that some criticism would arise from Campion's distinct narrative style, Phil's secret sexuality (predictable or not), and the various ways in which  The Power of the Dog  subverts typical Western masculinity . However, the strengths of the movie clearly overshadow its minor flaws.  The Power of the Dog has established itself as a very solid film at the critical and popular levels, even if it only won one of the 12 Oscars it was nominated for.

Related:  The Power of the Dog Wasted One Of Its Biggest Stars

Did Jane Campion deserve her Best Director Oscar?

Of all the Academy Awards it was nominated for, it makes sense that  The Power of the Dog 's win ultimately came in the form of Jane Campion's Best Director Oscar. Every aspect of the film is well-executed, which includes the acting, writing, production and sound design, and editing for which The Power of the Dog  was recognized in its 12 nominations. While the credit for these successes undoubtedly goes to all of the talented people who made them happen, the sum total of  The Power of the Dog 's meaning and resonance is largely due to Jane Campion's vision and her ability to direct the rest of the film's contributors towards achieving it. As such, it seems clear that her Academy Award for Best Director was well-deserved.

Was Power Of The Dog Robbed At The 2022 Oscars?

Given that  The Power of the Dog was nominated for a whopping 12 Oscars but only won one, it's easy to wonder if the film was snubbed at the 2022 Academy Awards. Its ratio of nominations to victories is quite low, but it's also important to remember that very few films are nominated for so many categories in the first place.  The Power of the Dog could very well have won more Oscars than it did. But, at the same time, it was up against many worthy competitors like CODA, King Richard, and Dune . Whether or not  The Power of the Dog was robbed or victorious at the 2022 Oscars is therefore simply a matter of perspective. Regardless of how it fared during awards season, the film has certainly established itself as an excellent, enduring piece of cinematic art, which is ultimately more important and better for Campion's legacy than a golden trophy.

Next:  The Power Of The Dog Ending Explained (In Detail)

• SR Originals
• The Power of the Dog

• Share full article

For more audio journalism and storytelling, download New York Times Audio , a new iOS app available for news subscribers.

• Apple Podcasts
• Google Podcasts

The Republican Plan to Challenge a Harris Victory

How a right-wing takeover of an obscure, unelected board in georgia could swing the election..

Hosted by Michael Barbaro

Featuring Nick Corasaniti

Produced by Olivia Natt Asthaa Chaturvedi and Eric Krupke

Edited by Patricia Willens

With Lexie Diao and Michael Benoist

Original music by Dan Powell Corey Schreppel Rowan Niemisto and Diane Wong

Engineered by Chris Wood

Listen and follow ‘The Daily’ Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Amazon Music | YouTube | iHeartRadio

At the Democratic National Convention, party officials are celebrating polls showing that Kamala Harris is now competitive with Donald Trump in every major swing state across the country.

But in one of those swing states, Republicans have laid the groundwork to challenge a potential Harris victory this fall, by taking over an obscure, unelected board.

Nick Corasaniti, a Times reporter who focuses on voting and elections, explains.

On today’s episode

Nick Corasaniti , a reporter covering national politics for The New York Times.

Background reading

The unelected body that shapes voting rules in Georgia has a new conservative majority, whose members question the state’s 2020 results. They now have new power to influence the results in 2024 .

Kamala Harris and Donald Trump are in close races across Arizona, Georgia, Nevada and North Carolina , crucial swing states that Mr. Trump had seemed poised to run away with.

There are a lot of ways to listen to The Daily. Here’s how.

We aim to make transcripts available the next workday after an episode’s publication. You can find them at the top of the page.

Fact-checking by Susan Lee .

The Daily is made by Rachel Quester, Lynsea Garrison, Clare Toeniskoetter, Paige Cowett, Michael Simon Johnson, Brad Fisher, Chris Wood, Jessica Cheung, Stella Tan, Alexandra Leigh Young, Lisa Chow, Eric Krupke, Marc Georges, Luke Vander Ploeg, M.J. Davis Lin, Dan Powell, Sydney Harper, Michael Benoist, Liz O. Baylen, Asthaa Chaturvedi, Rachelle Bonja, Diana Nguyen, Marion Lozano, Corey Schreppel, Rob Szypko, Elisheba Ittoop, Mooj Zadie, Patricia Willens, Rowan Niemisto, Jody Becker, Rikki Novetsky, Nina Feldman, Will Reid, Carlos Prieto, Ben Calhoun, Susan Lee, Lexie Diao, Mary Wilson, Alex Stern, Sophia Lanman, Shannon Lin, Diane Wong, Devon Taylor, Alyssa Moxley, Olivia Natt, Daniel Ramirez and Brendan Klinkenberg.

Our theme music is by Jim Brunberg and Ben Landsverk of Wonderly. Special thanks to Sam Dolnick, Paula Szuchman, Lisa Tobin, Larissa Anderson, Julia Simon, Sofia Milan, Mahima Chablani, Elizabeth Davis-Moorer, Jeffrey Miranda, Maddy Masiello, Isabella Anderson, Nina Lassam and Nick Pitman.

Nick Corasaniti is a Times reporter covering national politics, with a focus on voting and elections. More about Nick Corasaniti

Advertisement