Table 4. Summary of the role of frustration in mathematical problem-solving by study methods
Positive | Negative | Both | Omitted | Total | |
Qualitative | 3 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 6 |
Quantitative | - | 2 | - | - | 2 |
Mixed-Methods | - | 4 | 1 | 1 | 6 |
Theoretical | - | 1 | 5 | - | 6 |
Total | 3 | 8 | 7 | 2 | 20 |
* DeBellis & Goldin [ ] was included as a theoretical study as this is where the discussion of the role of frustration is dominant. |
[1] | Hannula, M., Emotions in problem solving, in , S.J. Cho Ed. 2015, pp. 269-288, Springer. . |
[2] | , et al., Affect in mathematics education: An introduction, , (2006), 113-122. doi: |
[3] | McCleod, D.B., The role of affect in mathematical problem solving, in , D.B. Mcleod and V.M. Adams Ed. 1989, pp. 20-36, Springer. . |
[4] | and , Dynamics of affective states during complex learning, , (2012), 145-157. doi: |
[5] | , Affective pathways and representation in mathematical problem solving, , (2000), 209-219. doi: |
[6] | Pekrun, R. and Stephens, E.J., Achievement emotions in higher education, in , J.C. Smart Ed. 2010, 25: 257-306, Springer. . |
[7] | , Emotion research in education: Theoretical and methodological perspectives on the integration of affect, motivation, and cognition, , (2006), 307-314. doi: |
[8] | , and , Stimulating student aesthetic response to mathematical problems by means of manipulating the extent of surprise, , (2017), 42-57. doi: |
[9] | and , Surprise and the aesthetic experience of university students: A design experiment, , (2016), 127-151. doi: |
[10] | and , Affect and meta-affect in mathematical problem solving: A representational perspective, , (2006), 131-147. doi: |
[11] | , et al., Curiosity...Confusion? Frustration! The role and sequencing of emotions during mathematics problem solving, , (2019), 121-137. doi: |
[12] | , et al., The role of epistemic emotions in mathematics problem solving, , (2015), 172-185. doi: |
[13] | and , Confused, now what? A Cognitive-Emotional Strategy Training (CEST) intervention for elementary students during mathematics problem solving, , (2020), 101879. doi: |
[14] | , et al., Elementary students' cognitive and affective responses to impasses during mathematics problem solving, , (2021), 104-124. doi: |
[15] | and , The roles of aesthetic in mathematical inquiry, , (2004), 261-284. doi: |
[16] | Galán, F.C. and Beal, C.R., EEG estimates of engagement and cognitive workload predict math problem solving outcomes, in , 2012, pp. 51-62, Springer. . |
[17] | , et al., Achievement emotions in mathematics: Design and evidence of validity of a self-report scale, , (2020), 233-247. doi: |
[18] | Chen, L., ., Riding an emotional roller-coaster: A multimodal study of young child's math problem solving activities, in , T. Barnes, M. Chi and M. Feng Ed. 2016, pp. 38-45. |
[19] | , et al., Beliefs and engagement structures: Behind the affective dimension of mathematical learning, , (2011), 547-560. doi: |
[20] | , Problem solving heuristics, affect, and discrete mathematics, , (2004), 56-60. doi: |
[21] | , Affective issues in mathematical problem solving: Some theoretical considerations, , (1988), 134-141. doi: |
[22] | , The role of affect in learning Real Analysis: A case study, , (2008), 71-85. doi: |
[23] | , Representational systems, learning, and problem solving in mathematics, , (1998), 137-165. |
[24] | , Student teachers' reflections on their learning process through collaborative problem solving in geometry, , (2004), 199-225. doi: |
[25] | , and , How are motivation and self-efficacy interacting in problem-solving and problem-posing?, , (2020), 487-517. doi: |
[26] | DeBellis, V.A. and Goldin, G. A., Interactions between cognition and affect in eight high school students' individual problem solving, in , R.G. Underhill Ed. 1991, pp. 29-35. Virginia Polytechnic University, Division of Curriculum and Instruction. |
[27] | and , The cyclic nature of problem solving: An emergent multidimensional problem-solving framework, , (2005), 45-75. doi: |
[28] | and , Visualization and affect in nonroutine problem solving, , (2001), 289-313. doi: |
[29] | O'Dell, J.R., The interplay of frustration and joy: Elementary students' productive struggle when engaged in unsolved problems, in , T.E. Hodges, G.J. Roy and A.M. Tyminski Ed. 2018, pp. 938-945. University of South Carolina & Clemson University. |
[30] | , Productive struggle in middle school mathematics classrooms, , (2015), 375-400. doi: |
[31] | , , Routledge, London, 1960. |
[32] | Vygotsky, L.S., , Ed. by R.W. Rieber and A.S. Carton. |
[33] | Pekrun, R., A social-cognitive, control-value theory of achievement emotions, in , J. Heckhausen, Ed. 2000, pp. 143-163, Elsevier. |
[34] | , and , Rethinking stress: The role of mindsets in determining the stress response, , (2013), 716-733. doi: |
[35] | , et al., The role of stress mindset in shaping cognitive, emotional, and physiological responses to challenging and threatening stress, , (2017), 379-395. doi: |
Tables ( 4 )
HTML views( 3402 ) PDF downloads( 511 ) Cited by( 0 )
Recent years have seen a significant progress in the general-purpose problem solving abilities of large vision and language models (LVLMs), such as ChatGPT, Gemini, etc.; some of these breakthroughs even seem to enable AI models to outperform human abilities in varied tasks that demand higher-order cognitive skills. Are the current large AI models indeed capable of generalized problem solving as humans do? A systematic analysis of AI capabilities for joint vision and text reasoning, however, is missing in the current scientific literature. In this paper, we make an effort towards filling this gap, by evaluating state-of-the-art LVLMs on their mathematical and algorithmic reasoning abilities using visuo-linguistic problems from children's Olympiads. Specifically, we consider problems from the Mathematical Kangaroo (MK) Olympiad, which is a popular international competition targeted at children from grades 1-12, that tests children's deeper mathematical abilities using puzzles that are appropriately gauged to their age and skills. Using the puzzles from MK, we created a dataset, dubbed SMART-840, consisting of 840 problems from years 2020-2024. With our dataset, we analyze LVLMs power on mathematical reasoning; their responses on our puzzles offer a direct way to compare against that of children. Our results show that modern LVLMs do demonstrate increasingly powerful reasoning skills in solving problems for higher grades, but lack the foundations to correctly answer problems designed for younger children. Further analysis shows that there is no significant correlation between the reasoning capabilities of AI models and that of young children, and their capabilities appear to be based on a different type of reasoning than the cumulative knowledge that underlies children's mathematics and logic skills.
Or search by topic
Working Systematically is part of our Developing Mathematical Thinking collection.
In Developing Mathematical Thinking - Working Sytematically we highlight the benefits of working systematically in a variety of contexts. Mathematicians often talk about the importance of working systematically. This means that rather than working in a haphazard and random way, there is a methodical, organised and logical approach. The problems below will challenge students to work systematically, and will help them appreciate the benefits of working in this way.
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
It is then useful to show children how they can use the skill to help them solve other types of problems. Ordered Ways of Working. i) Structuring a method for solving a problem. Systematic working is a useful tool for tackling many other kinds of problem. For example in Growing Garlic, a challenging lower primary activity, trying out possible ...
Problem Solving Strategy 2 (Draw a Picture). Some problems are obviously about a geometric situation, and it is clear you want to draw a picture and mark down all of the given information before you try to solve it. But even for a problem that is not geometric thinking visually can help! Videos to watch demonstrating how to use "Draw a Picture". 1.
A Problem Solving Strategy: Find the Math, Remove the Context. Sometimes the problem has a lot of details in it that are unimportant, or at least unimportant for getting started. The goal is to find the underlying math problem, then come back to the original question and see if you can solve it using the math.
1. Link problem-solving to reading. When we can remind students that they already have many comprehension skills and strategies they can easily use in math problem-solving, it can ease the anxiety surrounding the math problem. For example, providing them with strategies to practice, such as visualizing, acting out the problem with math tools ...
Developing Systematic Approaches. Mathematicians like to work systematically on a problem rather than approaching it in a random, unstructured way. The tasks in this feature are designed to provoke students to solve them in a systematic manner. 1 Step 2 Step. Age 11 to 14.
In Developing Mathematical Thinking - Working Systematically we highlight the benefits of working systematically in a variety of contexts. Mathematicians often talk about the importance of working systematically. This means that rather than working in a haphazard and random way, there is a methodical, organised and logical approach.
Teaching about problem solving begins with suggested strategies to solve a problem. For example, "draw a picture," "make a table," etc. You may see posters in teachers' classrooms of the "Problem Solving Method" such as: 1) Read the problem, 2) Devise a plan, 3) Solve the problem, and 4) Check your work. There is little or no ...
Problem Solving. What Is It? Teaching strategies for solving word problems is essential for students with mathematics difficulties. In order to create and solve problems from real-world data, students need to develop a set of skills and strategies for solving a range of problems (VDOE, 2020). Strategies for teaching problem solving include: 1.
There are many different ways to solve a math problem, and equipping students with problem-solving strategies is just as important as teaching computation and algorithms. Problem-solving strategies help students visualize the problem or present the given information in a way that can lead them to the solution. Solving word problems using …</p>
Mathematics provides a systematic and logical framework for problem-solving and critical thinking. The study of math helps to develop analytical skills, logical reasoning, and problem-solving abilities that can be applied to many areas of life.By using critical thinking skills to solve math problems, we can develop a deeper understanding of concepts, enhance our problem-solving skills, and ...
FREE Word Problem Templates: Simply enter your email here to receive this set of Editable Word Problem Solving Templates. You should receive them in an email shortly after submitting the form. You will also be added to my email list to receive teaching tips, freebies and special offers. First Name (optional) Email Address.
students' skills in solving mathematics problems. Hoon, Kee, Singh (2013) investigated students' response in applying ... solution drawing, systematic experimentation, way back and use of graphs of functions With the studies showing how strategies can improve mathematics problem solving, Koichu, Berman, and Moore (2004) aimed to
Developing Excellence in Problem Solving with Young Learners. Age 5 to 11. Becoming confident and competent as a problem solver is a complex process that requires a range of skills and experience. In this article, Jennie suggests that we can support this process in three principal ways. Using NRICH Tasks to Develop Key Problem-solving Skills.
Solution. First we must ensure we understand the problem. Lines can be either solid or broken and their are three lines. To be systematic, we could start with three solid lines and then gradually introduce broken lines. If there were two broken lines, there are three positions that the remaining solid line could be in.
But as far as I'm concerned, realizing how the mind constructs knowledge and understanding in a problem-solving task is an empowering notion. Alan Schoenfeld, mathematician and math- education specialist, has identified four aspects of the mental process of problem-solving that are essential: Resources, Heuristics, Control, and Belief.
Heuristic: Make a systematic list. Word Problem (Primary 2): Jimmy uses the number cards given below to form as many 3-digit odd numbers as he can. List all the numbers that Jimmy can form. Solution: 1. Understand: What to find: All the 3-digit odd numbers that Jimmy can form from the 4 number cards. What is known: Odd numbers end with 5 or 7.
The purpose of the present study is to examine the research that has been published since 2011 (i.e., end date of the previously published meta-analysis) on the impact of problem posing in mathematics education. 1.2 Problem Posing Problem-posing instruction is an approach to mathematics that comes in many forms.
A systematic review method was used to explore how frustration usually appears in students during mathematical problem-solving and the typical patterns of emotions, behaviours, and cognitive processes that are associated with its occurrence. The findings are mixed, which informs the need for further research in this area.
Working Systematically - Primary Students. Working Systematically is part of our Thinking Mathematically collection. Mathematicians often talk about the importance of working systematically. This means that rather than working in a haphazard and random way, there is a methodical, organised and logical approach. The problems below will challenge ...
A systematic review method was used to explore how frustration usually appears in students. during mathematical problem -solving and the typical patterns of emotions, behaviours, and cognitive ...
CPS task characteristics in mathematics ar e that it is a mathema tics problem- solving task (which expects students to use their problem-solving skills) bu t being put in a collaborative setting.
This page has been superseded by our Working Systematically - Primary Teachers page. Scroll down to see our complete collection of KS2 problems that require children to work systematically, or explore the two sub-collections focusing on important aspects of systematic working. This collection is one of our Primary Curriculum collections - tasks ...
Recent years have seen a significant progress in the general-purpose problem solving abilities of large vision and language models (LVLMs), such as ChatGPT, Gemini, etc.; some of these breakthroughs even seem to enable AI models to outperform human abilities in varied tasks that demand higher-order cognitive skills. Are the current large AI models indeed capable of generalized problem solving ...
Many dynamic processes can be described mathematically with the aid of stochastic partial differential equations. Scientists have found a new method which helps to solve a certain class of such ...
Working Systematically is part of our Developing Mathematical Thinking collection.. In Developing Mathematical Thinking - Working Sytematically we highlight the benefits of working systematically in a variety of contexts. Mathematicians often talk about the importance of working systematically. This means that rather than working in a haphazard and random way, there is a methodical, organised ...