lvalue is required as left operand of assignment

HatchJS.com

Cracking the Shell of Mystery

Lvalue Required as Left Operand of Assignment: What It Means and How to Fix It

Lvalue Required as Left Operand of Assignment

Have you ever tried to assign a value to a variable and received an error message like “lvalue required as left operand of assignment”? If so, you’re not alone. This error is a common one, and it can be frustrating to figure out what it means.

In this article, we’ll take a look at what an lvalue is, why it’s required as the left operand of an assignment, and how to fix this error. We’ll also provide some examples to help you understand the concept of lvalues.

So if you’re ever stuck with this error, don’t worry – we’re here to help!

In this tutorial, we will discuss what an lvalue is and why it is required as the left operand of an assignment operator. We will also provide some examples of lvalues and how they can be used.

What is an lvalue?

An lvalue is an expression that refers to a memory location. In other words, an lvalue is an expression that can be assigned a value. For example, the following expressions are all lvalues:

int x = 10; char c = ‘a’; float f = 3.14;

The first expression, `int x = 10;`, defines a variable named `x` and assigns it the value of 10. The second expression, `char c = ‘a’;`, defines a variable named `c` and assigns it the value of the character `a`. The third expression, `float f = 3.14;`, defines a variable named `f` and assigns it the value of 3.14.

Why is an lvalue required as the left operand of an assignment?

The left operand of an assignment operator must be a modifiable lvalue. This is because the assignment operator assigns the value of the right operand to the lvalue on the left. If the lvalue is not modifiable, then the assignment operator will not be able to change its value.

For example, the following code will not compile:

int x = 10; const int y = x; y = 20; // Error: assignment of read-only variable

The error message is telling us that the variable `y` is const, which means that it is not modifiable. Therefore, we cannot assign a new value to it.

Examples of lvalues

Here are some examples of lvalues:

• Variable names: `x`, `y`, `z`
• Arrays: `a[0]`, `b[10]`, `c[20]`
• Pointers: `&x`, `&y`, `&z`
• Function calls: `printf()`, `scanf()`, `strlen()`
• Constants: `10`, `20`, `3.14`

In this tutorial, we have discussed what an lvalue is and why it is required as the left operand of an assignment operator. We have also provided some examples of lvalues.

I hope this tutorial has been helpful. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask in the comments below.

3. How to identify an lvalue?

An lvalue can be identified by its syntax. Lvalues are always preceded by an ampersand (&). For example, the following expressions are all lvalues:

4. Common mistakes with lvalues

One common mistake is to try to assign a value to an rvalue. For example, the following code will not compile:

int x = 5; int y = x = 10;

This is because the expression `x = 10` is an rvalue, and rvalues cannot be used on the left-hand side of an assignment operator.

Another common mistake is to forget to use the ampersand (&) when referring to an lvalue. For example, the following code will not compile:

int x = 5; *y = x;

This is because the expression `y = x` is not a valid lvalue.

Finally, it is important to be aware of the difference between lvalues and rvalues. Lvalues can be used on the left-hand side of an assignment operator, while rvalues cannot.

In this article, we have discussed the lvalue required as left operand of assignment error. We have also provided some tips on how to identify and avoid this error. If you are still having trouble with this error, you can consult with a C++ expert for help.

Q: What does “lvalue required as left operand of assignment” mean?

A: An lvalue is an expression that refers to a memory location. When you assign a value to an lvalue, you are storing the value in that memory location. For example, the expression `x = 5` assigns the value `5` to the variable `x`.

The error “lvalue required as left operand of assignment” occurs when you try to assign a value to an expression that is not an lvalue. For example, the expression `5 = x` is not valid because the number `5` is not an lvalue.

Q: How can I fix the error “lvalue required as left operand of assignment”?

A: There are a few ways to fix this error.

• Make sure the expression on the left side of the assignment operator is an lvalue. For example, you can change the expression `5 = x` to `x = 5`.
• Use the `&` operator to create an lvalue from a rvalue. For example, you can change the expression `5 = x` to `x = &5`.
• Use the `()` operator to call a function and return the value of the function call. For example, you can change the expression `5 = x` to `x = f()`, where `f()` is a function that returns a value.

Q: What are some common causes of the error “lvalue required as left operand of assignment”?

A: There are a few common causes of this error.

• Using a literal value on the left side of the assignment operator. For example, the expression `5 = x` is not valid because the number `5` is not an lvalue.
• Using a rvalue reference on the left side of the assignment operator. For example, the expression `&x = 5` is not valid because the rvalue reference `&x` cannot be assigned to.
• Using a function call on the left side of the assignment operator. For example, the expression `f() = x` is not valid because the function call `f()` returns a value, not an lvalue.

Q: What are some tips for avoiding the error “lvalue required as left operand of assignment”?

A: Here are a few tips for avoiding this error:

• Always make sure the expression on the left side of the assignment operator is an lvalue. This means that the expression should refer to a memory location where a value can be stored.
• Use the `&` operator to create an lvalue from a rvalue. This is useful when you need to assign a value to a variable that is declared as a reference.
• Use the `()` operator to call a function and return the value of the function call. This is useful when you need to assign the return value of a function to a variable.

By following these tips, you can avoid the error “lvalue required as left operand of assignment” and ensure that your code is correct.

In this article, we discussed the lvalue required as left operand of assignment error. We learned that an lvalue is an expression that refers to a specific object, while an rvalue is an expression that does not refer to a specific object. We also saw that the lvalue required as left operand of assignment error occurs when you try to assign a value to an rvalue. To avoid this error, you can use the following techniques:

• Use the `const` keyword to make an rvalue into an lvalue.
• Use the `&` operator to create a reference to an rvalue.
• Use the `std::move()` function to move an rvalue into an lvalue.

We hope this article has been helpful. Please let us know if you have any questions.

Author Profile

Latest entries

• December 26, 2023 Error Fixing User: Anonymous is not authorized to perform: execute-api:invoke on resource: How to fix this error
• December 26, 2023 How To Guides Valid Intents Must Be Provided for the Client: Why It’s Important and How to Do It
• December 26, 2023 Error Fixing How to Fix the The Root Filesystem Requires a Manual fsck Error
• December 26, 2023 Troubleshooting How to Fix the `sed unterminated s` Command

Similar Posts

Adb vendor key not set: how to fix.

ADB Vendor Key Not Set: What It Is and How to Fix It If you’re a developer working with Android devices, you’ve probably come across the error message “ADB vendor key is not set.” This error can occur when you try to connect to an Android device using the Android Debug Bridge (ADB) tool. In…

NoneType object has no attribute find_all: What it means and how to fix it

NoneType Object Has No Attribute `find_all()` If you’re a Python developer, you’ve probably encountered the error message “NoneType object has no attribute `find_all()`”. This error occurs when you try to call the `find_all()` method on a variable that is of type `NoneType`. `NoneType` is a special type in Python that represents the absence of a…

Installing: Windows Subsystem for Linux Catastrophic Failure

Installing: Windows Subsystem for Linux Catastrophic Failure The Windows Subsystem for Linux (WSL) is a powerful tool that allows you to run Linux distributions on Windows 10. It’s a great way to get the best of both worlds, with the familiar Windows interface and the power of Linux. However, installing WSL can sometimes be a…

How to Fix cannot import name ‘baseresponse’ from ‘werkzeug.wrappers’

Have you ever encountered the error “cannot import name ‘baseresponse’ from ‘werkzeug.wrappers’”? If so, you’re not alone. This is a common error that can occur when you’re trying to use the Werkzeug framework in Python. In this article, we’ll take a look at what causes this error and how you can fix it. We’ll start…

Ctrl Alt N Not Working in VS Code: How to Fix

Ctrl Alt N Not Working in VS Code: A Quick Fix Visual Studio Code is a powerful code editor that’s used by developers of all skill levels. But even the best software can have its quirks, and one common problem is that the Ctrl Alt N shortcut doesn’t work. This can be a major pain,…

How to Fix Unable to Install TeamViewer: The Following Packages Have Unmet Dependencies

Unable to Install TeamViewer: The Following Packages Have Unmet Dependencies TeamViewer is a popular remote access and collaboration tool that allows users to control other computers remotely. However, some users may encounter an error message when trying to install TeamViewer that states “The following packages have unmet dependencies.” This error can occur for a variety…

Solve error: lvalue required as left operand of assignment

In this tutorial you will know about one of the most occurred error in C and C++ programming, i.e.  lvalue required as left operand of assignment.

lvalue means left side value. Particularly it is left side value of an assignment operator.

rvalue means right side value. Particularly it is right side value or expression of an assignment operator.

In above example  a  is lvalue and b + 5  is rvalue.

In C language lvalue appears mainly at four cases as mentioned below:

• Left of assignment operator.
• Left of member access (dot) operator (for structure and unions).
• Right of address-of operator (except for register and bit field lvalue).
• As operand to pre/post increment or decrement for integer lvalues including Boolean and enums.

Now let see some cases where this error occur with code.

When you will try to run above code, you will get following error.

Solution: In if condition change assignment operator to comparison operator, as shown below.

Above code will show the error: lvalue required as left operand of assignment operator.

Here problem occurred due to wrong handling of short hand operator (*=) in findFact() function.

Solution : Just by changing the line ans*i=ans to ans*=i we can avoid that error. Here short hand operator expands like this,  ans=ans*i. Here left side some variable is there to store result. But in our program ans*i is at left hand side. It’s an expression which produces some result. While using assignment operator we can’t use an expression as lvalue.

The correct code is shown below.

Above code will show the same lvalue required error.

Reason and Solution: Ternary operator produces some result, it never assign values inside operation. It is same as a function which has return type. So there should be something to be assigned but unlike inside operator.

The correct code is given below.

Some Precautions To Avoid This Error

There are no particular precautions for this. Just look into your code where problem occurred, like some above cases and modify the code according to that.

Mostly 90% of this error occurs when we do mistake in comparison and assignment operations. When using pointers also we should careful about this error. And there are some rare reasons like short hand operators and ternary operators like above mentioned. We can easily rectify this error by finding the line number in compiler, where it shows error: lvalue required as left operand of assignment.

Programming Assignment Help on Assigncode.com, that provides homework ecxellence in every technical assignment.

Comment below if you have any queries related to above tutorial.

Related Posts

Basic structure of c program, introduction to c programming language, variables, constants and keywords in c, first c program – print hello world message, 6 thoughts on “solve error: lvalue required as left operand of assignment”.

hi sir , i am andalib can you plz send compiler of c++.

i want the solution by char data type for this error

#include #include #include using namespace std; #define pi 3.14 int main() { float a; float r=4.5,h=1.5; {

a=2*pi*r*h=1.5 + 2*pi*pow(r,2); } cout<<" area="<<a<<endl; return 0; } what's the problem over here

#include using namespace std; #define pi 3.14 int main() { float a,p; float r=4.5,h=1.5; p=2*pi*r*h; a=1.5 + 2*pi*pow(r,2);

cout<<" area="<<a<<endl; cout<<" perimeter="<<p<<endl; return 0; }

You can't assign two values at a single place. Instead solve them differetly

Hi. I am trying to get a double as a string as efficiently as possible. I get that error for the final line on this code. double x = 145.6; int size = sizeof(x); char str[size]; &str = &x; Is there a possible way of getting the string pointing at the same part of the RAM as the double?

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

• school Campus Bookshelves
• menu_book Bookshelves
• perm_media Learning Objects
• login Login
• how_to_reg Request Instructor Account
• hub Instructor Commons

Margin Size

• Download Page (PDF)
• Download Full Book (PDF)
• Periodic Table
• Physics Constants
• Scientific Calculator
• Reference & Cite
• Tools expand_more
• Readability

selected template will load here

This action is not available.

4.7: L Value and R Value

• Last updated
• Save as PDF
• Page ID 29039

• Patrick McClanahan
• San Joaquin Delta College

\( \newcommand{\vecs}[1]{\overset { \scriptstyle \rightharpoonup} {\mathbf{#1}} } \)

\( \newcommand{\vecd}[1]{\overset{-\!-\!\rightharpoonup}{\vphantom{a}\smash {#1}}} \)

\( \newcommand{\id}{\mathrm{id}}\) \( \newcommand{\Span}{\mathrm{span}}\)

( \newcommand{\kernel}{\mathrm{null}\,}\) \( \newcommand{\range}{\mathrm{range}\,}\)

\( \newcommand{\RealPart}{\mathrm{Re}}\) \( \newcommand{\ImaginaryPart}{\mathrm{Im}}\)

\( \newcommand{\Argument}{\mathrm{Arg}}\) \( \newcommand{\norm}[1]{\| #1 \|}\)

\( \newcommand{\inner}[2]{\langle #1, #2 \rangle}\)

\( \newcommand{\Span}{\mathrm{span}}\)

\( \newcommand{\id}{\mathrm{id}}\)

\( \newcommand{\kernel}{\mathrm{null}\,}\)

\( \newcommand{\range}{\mathrm{range}\,}\)

\( \newcommand{\RealPart}{\mathrm{Re}}\)

\( \newcommand{\ImaginaryPart}{\mathrm{Im}}\)

\( \newcommand{\Argument}{\mathrm{Arg}}\)

\( \newcommand{\norm}[1]{\| #1 \|}\)

\( \newcommand{\Span}{\mathrm{span}}\) \( \newcommand{\AA}{\unicode[.8,0]{x212B}}\)

\( \newcommand{\vectorA}[1]{\vec{#1}}      % arrow\)

\( \newcommand{\vectorAt}[1]{\vec{\text{#1}}}      % arrow\)

\( \newcommand{\vectorB}[1]{\overset { \scriptstyle \rightharpoonup} {\mathbf{#1}} } \)

\( \newcommand{\vectorC}[1]{\textbf{#1}} \)

\( \newcommand{\vectorD}[1]{\overrightarrow{#1}} \)

\( \newcommand{\vectorDt}[1]{\overrightarrow{\text{#1}}} \)

\( \newcommand{\vectE}[1]{\overset{-\!-\!\rightharpoonup}{\vphantom{a}\smash{\mathbf {#1}}}} \)

What am L (or R) Value?

They refer to on the left and right side of the assignment operator. The Lvalue (pronounced: L value) concept refers to the requirement that the operand on the left side of the assignment operator is modifiable, usually a variable. Rvalue concept pulls or fetches the value of the expression or operand on the right side of the assignment operator. Some examples:

The value 39 is pulled or fetched (Rvalue) and stored into the variable named age (Lvalue); destroying the value previously stored in the age variable.

If the expression has a variable or named constant on the right side of the assignment operator, it would pull or fetch the value stored in the variable or constant. The value 18 is pulled or fetched from the variable named voting_age and stored into the variable named age.

If the expression is a test expression or Boolean expression , the concept is still an Rvalue one. The value in the identifier named age is pulled or fetched and used in the relational comparison of less than.

This is illegal because the identifier JACK_BENNYS_AGE does not have Lvalue properties. It is not a modifiable data object, because it is a constant.

Definitions

Adapted from:  "Lvalue and Rvalue"  by  Kenneth Leroy Busbee , (Download for free at http://cnx.org/contents/[email protected] ) is licensed under  CC BY 4.0

【C】报错[Error] lvalue required as left operand of assignment

[Error] lvalue required as left operand of assignment

计算值为== ！=

 赋值语句的左边应该是变量，不能是表达式。而实际上，这里是一个比较表达式，所以要把赋值号（＝）改用关系运算符（＝＝）

“相关推荐”对你有帮助么？

请填写红包祝福语或标题

1.余额是钱包充值的虚拟货币，按照1:1的比例进行支付金额的抵扣。 2.余额无法直接购买下载，可以购买VIP、付费专栏及课程。

Understanding and Resolving the 'lvalue Required: Left Operand Assignment' Error in C++

Abstract: In C++ programming, the 'lvalue Required: Left Operator Assignment' error occurs when assigning a value to an rvalue. In this article, we'll discuss the error in detail, provide examples, and discuss possible solutions.

Understanding and Resolving the "lvalue Required Left Operand Assignment" Error in C++

In C++ programming, one of the most common errors that beginners encounter is the "lvalue required as left operand of assignment" error. This error occurs when the programmer tries to assign a value to an rvalue, which is not allowed in C++. In this article, we will discuss the concept of lvalues and rvalues, the causes of this error, and how to resolve it.

Lvalues and Rvalues

In C++, expressions can be classified as lvalues or rvalues. An lvalue (short for "left-value") is an expression that refers to a memory location and can appear on the left side of an assignment. An rvalue (short for "right-value") is an expression that does not refer to a memory location and cannot appear on the left side of an assignment.

For example, consider the following code:

In this code, x is an lvalue because it refers to a memory location that stores the value 5. The expression x = 10 is also an lvalue because it assigns the value 10 to the memory location referred to by x . However, the expression 5 is an rvalue because it does not refer to a memory location.

Causes of the Error

The "lvalue required as left operand of assignment" error occurs when the programmer tries to assign a value to an rvalue. This is not allowed in C++ because rvalues do not have a memory location that can be modified. Here are some examples of code that would cause this error:

In each of these examples, the programmer is trying to assign a value to an rvalue, which is not allowed. The error message indicates that an lvalue is required as the left operand of the assignment operator ( = ).

Resolving the Error

To resolve the "lvalue required as left operand of assignment" error, the programmer must ensure that the left operand of the assignment operator is an lvalue. Here are some examples of how to fix the code that we saw earlier:

In each of these examples, we have ensured that the left operand of the assignment operator is an lvalue. This resolves the error and allows the program to compile and run correctly.

The "lvalue required as left operand of assignment" error is a common mistake that beginners make when learning C++. To avoid this error, it is important to understand the difference between lvalues and rvalues and to ensure that the left operand of the assignment operator is always an lvalue. By following these guidelines, you can write correct and efficient C++ code.

• C++ Primer (5th Edition) by Stanley B. Lippman, Josée Lajoie, and Barbara E. Moo
• C++ Programming: From Problem Analysis to Program Design (5th Edition) by D.S. Malik
• "lvalue required as left operand of assignment" on cppreference.com

Learn how to resolve 'lvalue Required: Left Operand Assignment' error in C++ by understanding the concept of lvalues and rvalues and applying the appropriate solutions.

Accepting multiple positional arguments in bash/shell: a better way than passing empty arguments.

In this article, we will discuss a better way of handling multiple positional arguments in Bash/Shell scripts without passing empty arguments.

Summarizing Bird Detection Data with plyr in R

In this article, we explore how to summarize bird detection data using the plyr package in R. We will use a dataframe containing 11,000 rows of bird detections over the last 5 years, and we will apply various summary functions to extract meaningful insights from the data.

Tags: :  C++ Programming Error Debugging

Latest news

• Global Variable Value Changes in VSCode: Set, Get, and Modify Functions
• Creating a Save System: Overcoming Setting Problems in Room-Based Games
• Automating Tab Color Macro Checking and Value Changing in Excel Worksheets
• Writing a Single-Row SELECT Query for Multiple Many-to-Many Relationships in SQL
• Stuck: Diagnosing PIM Activations in Azure DevOps using KQL
• Concatenating Environment Variables in application.yaml for Kubernetes and Java
• Modifying Pre-trained TensorFlow Image Classification Model to Classify 3 Classes
• Properly Managing Monitor Locks in PostgreSQL: A Case Study
• Jupyter Notebook: Cells with Geoscatterplot from Plotly Library Not Rendering - Solutions
• GNURadio: Creating HD-SIG GEN GUI Example - Title
• Calculate Mileage Between Two Locations using Google Sheets and Google Maps
• Connecting Azure Storage Account to Azure Databricks: Fetch Data using MSI Authentication
• Python Poker: Implementing Find Pair Set Cards
• Running Hadoop Jobs on Windows 10: Unsupported Operation Exception
• Performing Hard Deletes with PySpark and Hudi on AWS Glue: A Solution
• Reading CSV Files with Newlines in SQL DB using ADF: A Practical Guide
• Possible Variable Name Changes in Thinking Python: A Code Discussion
• Media Query in Material-UI React App: Top-Level Component Issue
• Unable to Read Images DLL in Software Development: A Common Issue
• React Router and Apache2: Setting Up a Route for a ReactJS Application
• Docker Container Doesn't Keep Deployed Swarm Network
• Developing a VSCode Extension: Highlighting Continued Extended Selection
• Migrating a Wordpress Website to Dynamic Interactive Frontend using React/Vue with Elementor
• Removing Duplicates with Matrices: A Refresher
• Enabling a Panable Listbox in Tkinter GUI
• Understanding Local/External Transitions in UML: Execution Order and Multiple Hierarchical Levels
• Performance Analysis of Numpy Array Operations with Different Shapes
• Mentioned Names 'Hudson' and 'John' in Excel: A1, B1, and C1
• Adding a Custom Certificate to Trusted Rubies on MacOS using Homebrew
• Understanding Bind Mounts in Docker Compose
• Manually Merging YAML Files in Spring Boot 3 for Custom Profiles
• Combining HashCodes in Sensitive Order using IReadOnlySet<T> in .NET
• Spring Boot 3.3.0 JPA Validation Fails: Updating from Spring Boot 3.2.3
• Fixing Python Package Unit Tests Timeout Issues in Project Directories
• Fine-Tuning Pretrained BERT Model for ABSA and Sentiment Analysis

• C Data Types
• C Operators
• C Input and Output
• C Control Flow
• C Functions
• C Preprocessors
• C File Handling
• C Cheatsheet
• C Interview Questions

lvalue and rvalue in C language

• Difference Between C Language and LISP Language
• Print an Integer Value in C
• Variable Length Arrays (VLAs) in C
• Storage of integer and character values in C
• Local Variable in C
• Understanding Lvalues, PRvalues and Xvalues in C/C++ with Examples
• Security issues in C language
• How to print a variable name in C?
• Else without IF and L-Value Required Error in C
• rand() and srand() in C++
• A Puzzle on C/C++ R-Value Expressions
• C Language | Set 2
• C Language | Set 1
• lrint() and llrint() in C++
• C Language | Set 10
• Default values in a Map in C++ STL
• Lex Program to accept a valid integer and float value
• Maximum value of unsigned char in C++
• Pointers and References in C++

lvalue:- 

lvalue simply means an object that has an identifiable location in memory (i.e. having an address).

• In any assignment statement “lvalue” must have the capability to store the data.
• lvalue cannot be a function, expression (like a+b) or a constant (like 3 , 4 , etc.).

L-value : “l-value” refers to memory location which identifies an object. l-value may appear as either left hand or right hand side of an assignment operator(=). l-value often represents as identifier. Expressions referring to modifiable locations are called “ modifiable l-values “. A modifiable l-value cannot have an array type, an incomplete type, or a type with the const attribute. For structures and unions to be modifiable lvalues , they must not have any members with the const attribute. The name of the identifier denotes a storage location, while the value of the variable is the value stored at that location. An identifier is a modifiable lvalue if it refers to a memory location and if its type is arithmetic, structure, union or pointer. For example, if ptr is a pointer to a storage region, then *ptr is a modifiable l-value that designates the storage region to which ptr points. In C, the concept was renamed as “locator value” , and referred to expressions that locate (designate) objects. The l-value is one of the following:

• The name of the variable of any type i.e. , an identifier of integral, floating, pointer, structure, or union type.
• A subscript ([ ]) expression that does not evaluate to an array.
• A unary-indirection (*) expression that does not refer to an array
• An l-value expression in parentheses.
• A const object (a nonmodifiable l-value).
• The result of indirection through a pointer, provided that it isn’t a function pointer.
• The result of member access through pointer(-> or .)

p = &a; // ok, assignment of address // at l-value

&a = p; // error: &a is an r-value

( x < y ? y : x) = 0; // It’s valid because the ternary // expression preserves the "lvalue-ness" // of both its possible return values

r-value simply means, an object that has no identifiable location in memory (i.e. having an address).

• Anything that is capable of returning a constant expression or value.
• Expression like a+b will return some constant.

R-value : r-value” refers to data value that is stored at some address in memory. A r-value is an expression, that can’t have a value assigned to it, which means r-value can appear on right but not on left hand side of an assignment operator(=). 

Note : The unary & (address-of) operator requires an l-value as its operand. That is, &n is a valid expression only if n is an l-value. Thus, an expression such as &12 is an error. Again, 12 does not refer to an object, so it’s not addressable. For instance, 

Remembering the mnemonic, that l-values can appear on the left of an assignment operator while r-values can appear on the right.

Reference: https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/bkbs2cds.aspx

Please Login to comment...

Similar reads, improve your coding skills with practice.

What kind of Experience do you want to share?

Understanding lvalues and rvalues in C and C++

The terms lvalue and rvalue are not something one runs into often in C/C++ programming, but when one does, it's usually not immediately clear what they mean. The most common place to run into these terms are in compiler error & warning messages. For example, compiling the following with gcc :

True, this code is somewhat perverse and not something you'd write, but the error message mentions lvalue , which is not a term one usually finds in C/C++ tutorials. Another example is compiling this code with g++ :

Now the error is:

Here again, the error mentions some mysterious rvalue . So what do lvalue and rvalue mean in C and C++? This is what I intend to explore in this article.

A simple definition

This section presents an intentionally simplified definition of lvalues and rvalues . The rest of the article will elaborate on this definition.

An lvalue ( locator value ) represents an object that occupies some identifiable location in memory (i.e. has an address).

rvalues are defined by exclusion, by saying that every expression is either an lvalue or an rvalue . Therefore, from the above definition of lvalue , an rvalue is an expression that does not represent an object occupying some identifiable location in memory.

Basic examples

The terms as defined above may appear vague, which is why it's important to see some simple examples right away.

Let's assume we have an integer variable defined and assigned to:

An assignment expects an lvalue as its left operand, and var is an lvalue, because it is an object with an identifiable memory location. On the other hand, the following are invalid:

Neither the constant 4 , nor the expression var + 1 are lvalues (which makes them rvalues). They're not lvalues because both are temporary results of expressions, which don't have an identifiable memory location (i.e. they can just reside in some temporary register for the duration of the computation). Therefore, assigning to them makes no semantic sense - there's nowhere to assign to.

So it should now be clear what the error message in the first code snippet means. foo returns a temporary value which is an rvalue. Attempting to assign to it is an error, so when seeing foo() = 2; the compiler complains that it expected to see an lvalue on the left-hand-side of the assignment statement.

Not all assignments to results of function calls are invalid, however. For example, C++ references make this possible:

Here foo returns a reference, which is an lvalue , so it can be assigned to. Actually, the ability of C++ to return lvalues from functions is important for implementing some overloaded operators. One common example is overloading the brackets operator [] in classes that implement some kind of lookup access. std::map does this:

The assignment mymap[10] works because the non-const overload of std::map::operator[] returns a reference that can be assigned to.

Modifiable lvalues

Initially when lvalues were defined for C, it literally meant "values suitable for left-hand-side of assignment". Later, however, when ISO C added the const keyword, this definition had to be refined. After all:

So a further refinement had to be added. Not all lvalues can be assigned to. Those that can are called modifiable lvalues . Formally, the C99 standard defines modifiable lvalues as:

[...] an lvalue that does not have array type, does not have an incomplete type, does not have a const-qualified type, and if it is a structure or union, does not have any member (including, recursively, any member or element of all contained aggregates or unions) with a const-qualified type.

Conversions between lvalues and rvalues

Generally speaking, language constructs operating on object values require rvalues as arguments. For example, the binary addition operator '+' takes two rvalues as arguments and returns an rvalue:

As we've seen earlier, a and b are both lvalues. Therefore, in the third line, they undergo an implicit lvalue-to-rvalue conversion . All lvalues that aren't arrays, functions or of incomplete types can be converted thus to rvalues.

What about the other direction? Can rvalues be converted to lvalues? Of course not! This would violate the very nature of an lvalue according to its definition [1] .

This doesn't mean that lvalues can't be produced from rvalues by more explicit means. For example, the unary '*' (dereference) operator takes an rvalue argument but produces an lvalue as a result. Consider this valid code:

Conversely, the unary address-of operator '&' takes an lvalue argument and produces an rvalue:

The ampersand plays another role in C++ - it allows to define reference types. These are called "lvalue references". Non-const lvalue references cannot be assigned rvalues, since that would require an invalid rvalue-to-lvalue conversion:

Constant lvalue references can be assigned rvalues. Since they're constant, the value can't be modified through the reference and hence there's no problem of modifying an rvalue. This makes possible the very common C++ idiom of accepting values by constant references into functions, which avoids unnecessary copying and construction of temporary objects.

CV-qualified rvalues

If we read carefully the portion of the C++ standard discussing lvalue-to-rvalue conversions [2] , we notice it says:

An lvalue (3.10) of a non-function, non-array type T can be converted to an rvalue. [...] If T is a non-class type, the type of the rvalue is the cv-unqualified version of T. Otherwise, the type of the rvalue is T.

What is this "cv-unqualified" thing? CV-qualifier is a term used to describe const and volatile type qualifiers.

From section 3.9.3:

Each type which is a cv-unqualified complete or incomplete object type or is void (3.9) has three corresponding cv-qualified versions of its type: a const-qualified version, a volatile-qualified version, and a const-volatile-qualified version. [...] The cv-qualified or cv-unqualified versions of a type are distinct types; however, they shall have the same representation and alignment requirements (3.9)

But what has this got to do with rvalues? Well, in C, rvalues never have cv-qualified types. Only lvalues do. In C++, on the other hand, class rvalues can have cv-qualified types, but built-in types (like int ) can't. Consider this example:

The second call in main actually calls the foo () const method of A , because the type returned by cbar is const A , which is distinct from A . This is exactly what's meant by the last sentence in the quote mentioned earlier. Note also that the return value from cbar is an rvalue. So this is an example of a cv-qualified rvalue in action.

Rvalue references (C++11)

Rvalue references and the related concept of move semantics is one of the most powerful new features the C++11 standard introduces to the language. A full discussion of the feature is way beyond the scope of this humble article [3] , but I still want to provide a simple example, because I think it's a good place to demonstrate how an understanding of what lvalues and rvalues are aids our ability to reason about non-trivial language concepts.

I've just spent a good part of this article explaining that one of the main differences between lvalues and rvalues is that lvalues can be modified, and rvalues can't. Well, C++11 adds a crucial twist to this distinction, by allowing us to have references to rvalues and thus modify them, in some special circumstances.

As an example, consider a simplistic implementation of a dynamic "integer vector". I'm showing just the relevant methods here:

So, we have the usual constructor, destructor, copy constructor and copy assignment operator [4] defined, all using a logging function to let us know when they're actually called.

Let's run some simple code, which copies the contents of v1 into v2 :

What this prints is:

Makes sense - this faithfully represents what's going on inside operator= . But suppose that we want to assign some rvalue to v2 :

Although here I just assign a freshly constructed vector, it's just a demonstration of a more general case where some temporary rvalue is being built and then assigned to v2 (this can happen for some function returning a vector, for example). What gets printed now is this:

Ouch, this looks like a lot of work. In particular, it has one extra pair of constructor/destructor calls to create and then destroy the temporary object. And this is a shame, because inside the copy assignment operator, another temporary copy is being created and destroyed. That's extra work, for nothing.

Well, no more. C++11 gives us rvalue references with which we can implement "move semantics", and in particular a "move assignment operator" [5] . Let's add another operator= to Intvec :

The && syntax is the new rvalue reference . It does exactly what it sounds it does - gives us a reference to an rvalue, which is going to be destroyed after the call. We can use this fact to just "steal" the internals of the rvalue - it won't need them anyway! This prints:

What happens here is that our new move assignment operator is invoked since an rvalue gets assigned to v2 . The constructor and destructor calls are still needed for the temporary object that's created by Intvec(33) , but another temporary inside the assignment operator is no longer needed. The operator simply switches the rvalue's internal buffer with its own, arranging it so the rvalue's destructor will release our object's own buffer, which is no longer used. Neat.

I'll just mention once again that this example is only the tip of the iceberg on move semantics and rvalue references. As you can probably guess, it's a complex subject with a lot of special cases and gotchas to consider. My point here was to demonstrate a very interesting application of the difference between lvalues and rvalues in C++. The compiler obviously knows when some entity is an rvalue, and can arrange to invoke the correct constructor at compile time.

One can write a lot of C++ code without being concerned with the issue of rvalues vs. lvalues, dismissing them as weird compiler jargon in certain error messages. However, as this article aimed to show, getting a better grasp of this topic can aid in a deeper understanding of certain C++ code constructs, and make parts of the C++ spec and discussions between language experts more intelligible.

Also, in the new C++ spec this topic becomes even more important, because C++11's introduction of rvalue references and move semantics. To really grok this new feature of the language, a solid understanding of what rvalues and lvalues are becomes crucial.

For comments, please send me an email .

lvalue required as left operand of assignment

I am trying to get a basic robotic arm using pneumatics to work. I am getting an "lvalue required as left operand of assignment" error at the end of my code (in my bool function).

Here is the code:

Check all your 'if' statements for equality. You are incorrectly using the assignment operator '=' instead of the equality operator '=='.

An lvalue normally equates to a memory address, so the error message "lvalue required as left operand of assignment" in the expression:

• if (data = "A"){*

is saying the compiler does have a place in memory where to put "A". The reason is because you're trying to put a string variable ("A") into data , which is a char variable, not a string. Those data attributes don't match, so in effect it is saying that the data type of "A" doesn't match the data type for data so it doesn't know where to put the result.

Had you written:

• if (data = 'A') {*

you would not have had the same error message because the syntax is correct. That is, it has a memory address (the lvalue of data ) where it can place a single character, 'A'. However, it seems doubtful that the expression is really what you want (a semantic error). What you probably want is to compare data with 'A', as others have pointed out:

• if (data == 'A') {*

it is not data that is a problem (which is a legal lvalue), its the whole expression.

Try Ctrl-T and look at the result (as well as the errors generated by the compiler).

There are some warnings that should be fixed too

Related Topics

Demystifying the "Expression Must Be a Modifiable Lvalue" Error in C++

As C++ developers, we‘ve all likely encountered the dreaded "expression must be a modifiable lvalue" error at some point. This confusing compile-time error can be a roadblock, but if we take the time to truly understand it, it can help us write safer and more robust C++ code overall.

In this comprehensive guide, we‘ll demystify this error completely by looking at what it means, why it happens, how to diagnose it, and best practices to avoid it in the future. Let‘s get started!

What Exactly Does "Expression Must Be a Modifiable Lvalue" Mean in C++?

When the compiler throws this error, it‘s telling us that we tried to assign something to an expression that cannot be assigned to. Let‘s break it down word-by-word:

• Expression: This refers to any valid C++ expression like a variable, arithmetic operation, function call etc. Basically, any combination of literals, variables, operators and functions that evaluates to a value.
• Must be: The expression is expected to have a certain property.
• Modifiable: The property is that the expression can be modified/assigned to.
• Lvalue: An lvalue refers to an expression that represents a specific memory location. Lvalues have identifiable memory addresses that can be accessed and modified.

Put simply, the error occurs because we tried to assign a value to something that cannot be assigned to. The expression on the left hand side of the assignment operator = needs to be a modifiable lvalue.

This is because the assignment operator stores the rvalue (right hand side expression) at the location in memory represented by the lvalue (left hand side). For this modification of memory to work correctly, the lvalue must refer to a valid modifiable location.

Classifying Expressions as Lvalues and Rvalues

To really understand this error, we need to be clear on the difference between lvalues and rvalues in C++.

Lvalues are expressions that represent identifiable memory locations that can be accessed/modified in some way. Some key properties of lvalues:

• Have distinct memory addresses that can be accessed directly.
• Can appear on either side of the assignment operator ( = ).
• Can be used as operands with unary & address-of operator.
• Can be modified, if declared without const .

Some examples of lvalues:

• Named variables like int x;
• Dereferenced pointers like *ptr
• Array elements like myArray[5]
• Member fields like obj.member
• Function calls that return lvalue references like int& func()

Rvalues are expressions that do not represent identifiable memory locations. They cannot be assigned to. Some examples:

• Literals like 5 , 3.14 , ‘a‘ etc.
• Temporary values like those returned by functions
• Operators applied to operands producing temporary values like x + 5
• Functions returning non-reference types like int func()

So in summary, lvalues have identifiable memory locations and can appear on the left side of assignments whereas rvalues cannot.

Common Causes of the "Expression Must Be a Modifiable Lvalue" Error

Understanding lvalues vs rvalues, we can now look at some of the most common scenarios that cause this error:

1. Assigning to a Constant/Read-only Variable

When we declare a variable with const , it becomes read-only and its value cannot be changed. Trying to assign to it results in our error:

Similarly, assigning to a constant literal like a string also causes an error:

2. Assigning Inside a Condition Statement

Condition statements like if and while expect a boolean expression, not an assignment.

Accidentally using = instead of == leads to an assignment inside the condition, causing invalid code:

The condition x = 5 assigns 5 to x, when we meant to check if x == 5.

3. Confusing Precedence of Operators

The assignment operator = has lower precedence than other operators like + , * . So code like this:

Is treated as

This essentially tries to assign 10 to the temporary rvalue x + 5 , causing an error.

4. Assigning to the Wrong Operand in Declarations

When declaring multiple variables in one statement, we must take care to assign to the correct identifier on the left side:

This assigns 10 to y instead of x due to ordering.

5. Overloaded Assignment Operator Issues

Assignment operators can be overloaded in classes. If the overloaded assignment operator is not implemented correctly, it can lead to this error.

For example, overloaded assignment should return a modifiable lvalue but sometimes programmers mistakenly return a temporary rvalue instead.

6. Assigning to Temporary Rvalues

Temporary rvalues that get created in expressions cannot be assigned to:

Some other examples are trying to assign to literals directly or dereferencing an incorrect pointer location.

7. Assigning to Array Elements Incorrectly

Only modifiable lvalues pointing to valid memory can be assigned to.

Trying to assign to an out of bounds array index is invalid:

Diagnosing the Error in Your Code

Now that we‘ve seen common causes of the error, let‘s look at how to diagnose it when it shows up in our code:

• Examine the full error message – it will indicate the exact expression that is invalid.
• Ensure the expression can be assigned to based on its type – is it a modifiable lvalue?
• Double check precedences of operators on the line causing issues. Add parentheses if needed to force intended precedence.
• If assigning to a user-defined type, check if overloaded assignment operator is correct.
• For conditionals and loops, verify == and = are not mixed up.
• Make sure all variables being assigned to are valid, declared identifiers.
• If assigning to an array element, index boundaries must be correct.
• Look nearby for typos like swapping . and -> when accessing members.
• Enable all compiler warnings and pedantic errors to catch related issues.

With some careful analysis of the code and error messages, identifying the root cause becomes much easier.

Resolving the Error Through Correct Modifiable Lvalues

Once we diagnose the issue, it can be resolved by using a valid modifiable lvalue on the left hand side of the assignment:

• Declare normal variables without const that can be assigned to
• Use dereferenced pointers like *ptr = 5 instead of direct literals
• Call functions that return non-const lvalue references like int& func()
• Use array element indices that are in bounds
• Access member fields of objects correctly like obj.member not obj->member
• Store rvalues in temporary variables first before assigning
• Ensure operator precedence resolves properly by adding parentheses
• Return proper lvalue references from overloaded assignment operators

Let‘s see a couple of examples fixing code with this error:

1. Fixing Const Assignment

2. Fixing Conditional Assignment

3. Fixing Invalid Array Index

By properly understanding lvalues vs rvalues in C++, we can find and fix the root causes of this error.

Best Practices to Avoid "Expression Must Be a Modifiable Lvalue" Errors

Learning from the examples and causes above, we can establish coding best practices that help avoid these kinds of errors:

• Clearly understand difference between lvalues and rvalues before writing complex code.
• Enable all compiler warnings to catch errors early. Pay attention to warnings!
• Be very careful when overloading assignment operators in classes.
• Do not combine multiple assignments in one statement. Break them up over separate lines.
• Use const judiciously on values that do not need modification.
• Use static_assert to validate assumptions about types and constants.
• Use == for comparisons, = only for assignment. Avoid mixing them up.
• Be careful with operator precedence – add parentheses when unsure.
• Initialize variables properly when declared and avoid unintended fallthrough assignments.
• Use descriptive variable names and formatting for readability.
• Validate indices before accessing elements of arrays and vectors.
• Handle returned temporaries from functions carefully before assigning.
• Run regular static analysis on code to detect issues early.

Adopting these best practices proactively will help us write code that avoids lvalue errors.

Summary and Key Lessons

The cryptic "expression must be a modifiable lvalue" error in C++ is trying to tell us that we improperly tried assigning to something that cannot be assigned to in the language.

By learning lvalue/rvalue concepts deeply and following best practices around assignments, we can eliminate these kinds of bugs in our code.

Some key lessons:

• Lvalues represent identifiable memory locations that can be modified. Rvalues do not.
• Use non-const variables and valid references/pointers as left operands in assignments.
• Be extremely careful inside conditionals, loops and declarations.
• Understand and properly handle operator precedence and overloadable operators.
• Enable all compiler warnings to catch issues early.
• Adopt defensive programming practices with constants, arrays, temporaries etc.

Persistently applying these lessons will ensure we write assignment-bug-free C++ code!

You maybe like,

Related posts, a complete guide to initializing arrays in c++.

As an experienced C++ developer, few things make me more uneasy than uninitialized arrays. You might have heard the saying "garbage in, garbage out" –…

A Comprehensive Guide to Arrays in C++

Arrays allow you to store and access ordered collections of data. They are one of the most fundamental data structures used in C++ programs for…

A Comprehensive Guide to C++ Programming with Examples

Welcome friend! This guide aims to be your one-stop resource to learn C++ programming concepts through examples. Mastering C++ is invaluable whether you are looking…

A Comprehensive Guide to Initializing Structs in C++

Structs in C++ are an essential composite data structure that every C++ developer should know how to initialize properly. This in-depth guide will cover all…

A Comprehensive Guide to Mastering Dynamic Arrays in C++

As a C++ developer, few skills are as important as truly understanding how to work with dynamic arrays. They allow you to create adaptable data…

A Comprehensive Guide to Pausing C++ Programs with system("pause") and Alternatives

As a C++ developer, having control over your program‘s flow is critical. There are times when you want execution to pause – whether to inspect…